While I love St J and love Gathers game I think the 3 reasons given for him not signing are legit. He is an 18 yr old kid making an impt decision and he wants to make sure coach's health is not an issue, BE doesn't fall apart and become a non-football conf, and that we look like title contenders with more good recruits on board. Remember this kid can just about name his school and needs to make the best decision for himself. And believe me I am as disappointed as anyone that he isn't signing right now. It used to take me months to get over losing a recruit going all the way back to Albert King, Pearl Washinton,Tony Red Bruin, and even Frank Spoon James.
I dont buy those reasons and think there's somebody in his ear for several reasons.
1). The "new" Big East won't effect Gathers all that much. All existing schools will be here until he's at least a junior. Conference changes shouldn't be the issue for most 2012 recruits.
2). If gathers thought his health was an issue, why not just ask him? You're committed to him. Lavin didn't
Even know about his de-commit. Lavin was healthy enought to postpone his surgery a year and when he is recovering from surgery during signing week, there is a de-commit? Gathers could google Lavin's prognosis and still know that his 4-year survival with low grade prostate CA is excellent.
I'm not blaming Ricardo for this stuff, but somebody is working his family and/or advisors with a lot of ying yang behind the scenes. Hopefully Lavs feels well enough to take a flight down there at the next open recruiting period to set everybody straight.