Only an outsider to NY metro would say that!
Yeah...NYMag really knows their stuff. Look at the comments following. Also, writer ends with a link about how "Long Island" basketball is doing well, then link takes you to LIU vs. St. Francis boxscore. Both Brooklyn schools. Thanks, but I'll stick with NYMag for restaurant reviews.
I know its not a popular opinion but I've looked at the map and unless my eyes deceive me Brooklyn and Queens are part of Long Island.
Born in Queens, raised on LI, school in Manhattan and lived in Brooklyn for 8 years and through it all stood by the position that Queens and Brooklyn were part of LI whether whether those snobs in Nassau and Suffolk were willing to admit it or not.