MainMan, The difference is McNeil was NOT a Free Agent. He had 2 arbitration years left. Nimmo was a straight up FA at 29.Look, I'm glad we signed him and it's a friendly contract, but I'm also shocked it was so low.
Nimmo gets $162M.
McNeill gets $50M.
Bizarre.
Look at it like this from McNeil’s standpoint instead of getting $7.75(HIS Arb figure) or $6.25 (Mets figure) he’s locking in $12-13 M based on incentives for each of the next 2 years. That’s locking in an extra $15M (about). Then he signed for two more years at about $15M. (4 years 50-60M).
He will be 31 years old by THIS opening day meaning he was not going to be a FA until he was 33 almost 34. He would have been gambling that a 33/34 year old 2B with so so power would be in demand.
McNeil gets screwed because his service time was delayed because he didn’t make it to the Majors until he was older. The thinking is 33 year old (agree or disagree) won’t have that great a market. If he hits .320 maybe. But what if McNeil hits .260 in two years? No one would come near $15M for that.