Ah, the douchiness...and to think some of you lasted about 3 days without it...the streak is over. You better call Rivals up and tell them they don't know crap. Maybe you can get a job there since you clearly have the truth and they don't. I've never heard anyone use RSCI in the mainstream...it's Rivals and ESPN usually. Also, if your intent is to teach someone something, the whole approach of being a complete douchebag isn't that effective. Is it so hard to say "Yes, rivals rankings are included in the RSCI" instead of "OMG you are so dumb, pick your battles you fool. Detroit is like #10 in the nation!"?
First lets get one thing clear, the fact that you're a douche and the fact that your a dope are mutually exclusive (look it up).
You could still post your inane comments without the attitude and complete lack of respect you've shown on this board from the first thread you posted in and we'd have a much more civil discourse going on. I'm not holding my breath.
Regarding one service vs. a consensus, I understand, you've never heard of RSCI so it must not have any importance or relevance. I'm assuming the same goes for Heather Thomas and Adrian Zmed. William Shatner on the other hand . . .
Now regarding a consensus average, well I think you refered to it once so I'll assume you understand the concept. There are plenty of talent evaluators and they can all see things differently. RSCI takes the top six or so each year and works out an average thereby eliminating deviations like when Rivals ranks someone 48 and everyone else has a player in the 20's. I'm sorry if you've never heard of it but it's commonly accepted as the best recruiting ranking on the web if only because it takes into account every major recruiting experts opinion, not just those you've heard of. Of course you've only heard of Rivals and ESPN, to know more than those would be to show a level of expertise on the subject that all your posts show you clearly do not possess.
However, because all they do is aggregate and average out the rankings RSCI really doesn't have much (read: any) staff so I don't think I could get a job there and besides, I'm positive they could not afford me.
Finally, I'll pick the battles I want to and they'll usually be the ones where I can make you look like an arrogant, obnoxious fool, but thanks for the attempt at advice.