I don't really agree, to be honest. Davis was an All-American and ACC POY. They won the regular season title and made it to the Sweet 16. Davis was the man on that team and is now playing his fifth year with them. Expectations were that he would carry them as a Final Four contender. Torvik had them in the preseason at number five!!! There's no change of scenery excuse for him. Lurking in the Trilly discord at that time, it was also clear he sucked UNC's NIL almost dry himself. He was a preseason All-American this year and probably a favorite to win national player of the year.Not to go down this rabbit hole but
A) Karaban is actually having a pretty damn good season so far.
B) Davis’ numbers are down some because UNC doesn’t have anybody close to the gravitational pull that Bacot had, but he’s far from the biggest disappointment in the country this year.
Off the top of my head I’d say Coleman Hawkins, AJ Storr and Johnell Davis clear both of those guys by a pretty large margin.
Now? UNC is barely a bubble team. Davis' stats have perked up because of these last few games but he's had total clunkers against their top teams. The team is a total mess.
I get that all three of the guys you mentioned have had less impact and their stats are considerably worse. But disappointing wise? Davis takes the cake.