I think this was a very classic "Pitino speak" thing. He knows its a dump and its really not a good place to see a game, but he was being very nice in making fans and the administration feel good about how bad Carnesseca is by saying it.
But there's no statistical evidence that we win games at CA that we would lose at MSG or anywhere else (forget the buy games in November. I did a BE conference match-up comparison and its very event).
And anecdotically, I don't remember any games where any one of us have posted "wow, being at CA really gave us the edge in that one." We've lost just as many heartbreakers, close games, etc. -- and typically with our guys doing the stupid stuff at the end of it.