Hiring a mid-major Coach is a risk (although any hire you make comes with an element of risk). However, it worked out well for Villanova when they hired Jay Wright, Duke when they hired Coach K. and Providence when they hired Ed Cooley to name but a few. St. John's went that route only once since Lou retired and that was with Fran Fraschilla. While here, he coached well and was probably our best post-Lou recruiter, putting together a roster that went to the Elite Eight and had future NBA players on it. Of course there were personal issues that let to Coach Fraschilla's demise, but it was neither his ability to recruit or his coaching acumen that did him in here.
Speedy Claxton has had a relatively brief coaching tenure and it is hard to fully evaluate his immediate successes as something that will be sustainable or will translate to a Program like ours. However, catching someone on the way up has worked in other places and it could work for us if we get the right guy.
Who is that right guy ?
Now that is the million dollar question that SJU desperately needs to answer correctly