beast of the east
Active member
My inane thoughts:
1. The Reed, Clippard, Familia 7-8-9 is better than average. Robles has good. He is young and crazy, but has talent. Gilmartin, Verrett, Torres, Goedell are nice long man options. Parnell, O'(h no) Flaherty, et al will not see a sliver of the postseason. Besides, the Dodger pen is shaky at best.
2. I would start Thor. His numbers in the first inning are not good, so I don't want to chance it. Also, if he is on, he can be nearly untouchable.
3. I like DeGrom, Syndergaard, Harvey, Matz if the Mets have home field. If the Dodgers have it, swap Harvey and Syndergaard. They will each pitch once (except DeGrom if needed), which saves their innings.
4. The team won 11 straight road games, and they had a couple of clunkers. This was bound to happen. Get it out of the system now.
5. After the Cespedes scare, I didn't care one about the game. We can agree, the bigger picture was the health of Cespedes. That was a fine trade off.
It's a good discussion, but better than average doesn't win a championship because most average adn below average bullpens will be watching the playoffs from home. The Mets have a pretty good history in this regard (moving a starter to the bullpen). Both Nolan Ryan and El Sid were moved to the bullpen in our only WS championships.
Ryan and El Sid were 5th starters. So in keeping with tradition, the Mets are auditioning Colon and Niese for the bullpen.
If I were to say the Mets bullpen, especially 7-8-9 is as good as anyone, would that be better? We are most familiar with the clunkers on the Mets staff. But all playoff teams are concerned about it. The best of the bunch may be Pittsburgh, but they have an extra game to play.
Besides, I am worried about LA first. And that bullpen is average.
I respect your opinion, something that isn't said around here enough.
I don't recollect if Cardwell was viewed as the 5th starter in 69, but both of the pitchers I mentioned were sent to the pen because they had nasty stuff and could dominate hitters, not because they were 5th starters. El Sid always had the lowest or near the lowest .BAA in the NL. Ryan we know about. Recalling the 88 playoff where Herschiser said, "I won't throw on the days to throw - just stick me in the bullpen." and as a reliever was lights out also. The Dodgers having a crappy bullpen won't help our pitchers in the 6th or 7th inning when our erratic relievers are on the mound.