Coach Lavin is going nowhere for awhile unless he wants to depart, which seems unlikely. It ought to be apparent to anyone who has followed the program over the years that St John's does not demand or expect that the basketball program compete at the level of a consistent top-20 program (in Big East terms this would include Georgetown and Villanova, for example). St. John's is satisfied to have a program that is free from NCAA investigation, sells 6,000 tickets per game, is in consideration for the NCAA tournament every few years, and makes the NIT when it doesn't make the NCAAs.
Coach Lavin will certainly deliver that, and in fact i think he will do somewhat better than that, which will make the administration and some of the fan base very happy. A large part of our fan base only really cares about wins and losses, and most of them are realistic enough to bear in mind that we have never been a truly top-tier program (this is why our legend player/team is a loss in the Final Four and not a victory in the championship game).
On the other hand, those who are longtime fans of college basketball will probably never be happy with Coach Lavin, unless he hires an experienced tactician and delegates substantially. His current approach of playing what is essentially NBA basketball (isolation, pick and roll, pick and pop) grates on the nerves of fans who want to see ball movement, player movement, open shots, and designed plays. And even his fans seem to agree that he lacks the feel for game coaching, which shows up in substitutions, time-outs, etc.
In the end, coaching bad basketball that wins 20 games is probably not a fire-able offense, and certainly not in the St John's world.
The good news is that there has been some good basketball played in the Big East Tournament this year, and there will be more to come in the NCAA Tournament.
The other good news is that with Xavier's win the league is up to 3 bids, and if Providence survives Seton Hall tomorrow the league should get 4. That should match the A-10, and isn't bad for a year in which so much of the league was mediocre.
It's time to put this conversation behind us, find some well-coached and well-played games to watch, and enjoy the sport.
Plenty of well-coached and well-played games going on in NYC this weekend in the same place that they were going on last weekend.....up at Fordham, and between Catholic High School teams. Being able to teach kids fundamentally sound basketball is not a lost art.