I ask you Redmen posters this ( and maybe white America in general), what defines a thug?
You're in luck, I'm not only a Redman poster but this is my week to be the spokes[strike]man[/strike]person for white america in general. Assuming that you're the spokesthug for black america in general I think we can have a meaningful conversation that may well advance race relations in this country into the 20th century.
No. Bernie Madoff committed a crime and he is not a thug
No, Cher has tattoos and she's an Academy Award winner. If you're calling the star of Moonstruck a thug we're going to have to settle this outside.
Is it saying something negative towards another person?
No, Don Rickles said a bunch of negative things towards a bunch of people and he's not a thug, he's an insult comic. Me as well, I talk shit about everyone all the time and I'm continually assured that it's because I got my lunch money stolen when I was in the fourth grade. Which is the opposite of thuggish.
Or finally, is it a person who acts up from societal norm standards?
Yeah, no, it's not. Oscar Wilde acted differently from "societal norm standards" (societal norms? societal standards? normal standards? standards? norms? why use one words when three will do, I'm guessing you have a graduate degree) which acting differently ended him up in prison and he was about the direct opposite of a thug. As was Gandhi, who also acted differently from societal norms and he wasn't a thug, this despite the fact that the word thug derives from tuggee, a hindi word meaning deceivers that referred to a criminal organization that terrorized the Indian subcontinent for six centuries and he was Indian.
So anyway are those the only options? Crime, tattoos, negative words, and acting weird? Because I think thug is like porn, I know one when I see one. Like Sam Gravano, he was a thug. And Jimmy Burke, he was a thug, and Eric Devendorf he was one. And Marvin Barnes was one, and Lemuel Smith. On the other hand Bill Cosby is not a thug, and he's perhaps a criminal who some ignorant people might call (as my boon companion spells it) a "N-----R." And on the other hand some ignorant people might call Oprah the N word but no one would call her a thug. See? Words are hard, aren't they, especially when you're being distracted by dog whistles.
You guys are using that word loosely without very clear consistency and as a African -American, that is very annoying and so unfair.
Here we can agree. As the spokesperson for white america I can assure you that people using words loosely is very annoying and unfair. Words that I find annoying and unfair when they're used loosely are "racist," "nazi," and "white supremacist." Also it drives me crazy when people confuse comprise and compose. And when people spell lose "loose" I want to run amok.
It’s like what Richard Sherman ( Stanford Educated Cornerback for Seattle) said, it seems you guys are using “thug” because America’s racial antecedent treatment towards blacks have made the word N*****r socially inadmissible. As a fan of Dave East the only thing he’s been guilty of, was blowing his basketball scholarship ( University of Richmond) so he could protect his brother who was about to be killed in Harlem ( seems very un-thug like to me).
I'm not familar with this Dave East fellow, but I'd wonder whether his brother was being threatened by thugs and if not who he was being threatened by and if so how he protected him? Was it with a gun? Or did he merely act outside of societal normal standards. Do tell.