I don’t understand how anyone in the world can possibly believe that either firing Anderson OR having him leave for Tulsa makes St Johns a MORE desirable job than it was when he was hired and we were fortunate to land him given some of the other options.
I find this board to be a place where (mostly) reasonable fans can have an informed, respectful debate but on other forms of social media there is a lack of intelligence and self-awareness regarding the program that just blows my mind. Clamoring for a well respected coach (regardless of if you personally respect him this is how he’s perceived in the coaching community) to be fired for underperforming for the first time just one season after we all praise him for winning Big East COY and OVERperforming makes this fanbase seem schizophrenic at best. Cragg & Anderson haven’t been waiting for this program to right the ship for 20+ years like the fans have. Certain portions of this fanbase should stop unloading all the frustration for those years into this one season of dissapointment. Cragg and Coach have been here for 3 and people are calling for their heads and wishing they’d leave. Careful what you wish for.
I generally agree with this level-headed sentiment, and I like CMA, but frankly it is very difficult to imagine anything other than continued mediocrity at best for at least the next season or two under status quo, and perhaps much worse. And then what? I gradually took off my rose-colored glasses this season and became realistic about the relative lack of national success CMA has had over the past 20 years, and am not convinced his past results are not the ceiling for him at SJU in an absolute best case scenario. Folks are desperate to make a real leap towards national relevance and have been waiting since 2000 to see it. Hard to blame at least one significant faction on here for wanting to bring in Rick, I've actually gotten there myself.