Preston Murphy was caught up in an investigation of college basketball but proclaimed his innocence. Nate Oates gave him a second chance.
theathletic.com
2 of 2
In 2014, McDermott reached out to Oats. He was looking to hire an assistant and trusted Oats from his days recruiting at Romulus. McDermott asked him: Who’s the best recruiter that came through your gym? “I said Preston Murphy,” Oats recalls.
It took another year, but the
Creighton coach eventually hired Murphy on his staff. “I was really impressed with his enthusiasm and his passion and knew that with a little experience, he was going to be terrific,” McDermott says, “and obviously when I hired him, he did not disappoint.”
Murphy instantly became one of McDermott’s best assistants, both from an Xs and Os perspective but also as a recruiter. He was pivotal in the Bluejays landing Ty-Shon Alexander and Marcus Zegarowski — a pair of eventual All-Big East guards — and, in McDermott’s words, “had his fingerprints all over our Big East championship team” in 2020. In Murphy’s four seasons in Omaha, Creighton won 82 games and made two NCAA Tournaments.
But in March 2019 — a year and a half after the FBI first announced 10 arrests as part of its investigation into college basketball — a federal indictment accused Murphy of accepting $6,000 from an undercover FBI agent during a meeting between Murphy and Dawkins. A day later, Creighton placed Murphy on administrative leave; he ultimately resigned the following November. According to Murphy’s attorney, Murphy passed a polygraph test that said he did not keep the money, take action with it, or maintain any relationship with Dawkins after that meeting. “The old ‘innocent until proven guilty’ didn’t really apply in those scenarios,” McDermott says, “and at Creighton, we did everything we could to keep him employed and support him during that process.”
In June 2021, the NCAA hit Murphy with a two-year show cause. McDermott reckons Murphy called him or Creighton director of operations Jeff Vanderloo almost every day during that time — and he still does now. During the time away from college hoops, Murphy coached at the grassroots level and attended multiple
NBA and college practices, trying to stay connected with the game while simultaneously sharpening his craft. He spent time with the Pacers and Celtics, as well as
UConn, Rhode Island, and Boston College.
“I just wanted to stay around the game, “Murphy says. “It was something that I wanted to take advantage of the time not coaching, and get better at my craft … Stay in tune with the latest trends.”
He also maintained his longstanding relationship with Oats, who by then had taken the Alabama job. “He got screwed through that whole thing, but every time I called him, he had the most positive outlook on life,” Oats says. “He’s just a guy you want around your program.” ”
Oats had to wait until June for Murphy’s show cause to expire, but he was willing to do so.
“He’s one of the best recruiters, best people in this business,” Oats says. “I had an opening, I needed a great recruiter — so it was a great mesh.”
Murphy’s first task at Alabama?
Taking over as the lead recruiter for five-star 2024 forward
Jarin Stevenson, and convincing him to reclassify to 2023. “Preston came right in and started recruiting me,” Stevenson says. “He was the main one.”
Murphy and Stevenson knew each other from their respective time in grassroots ball — although their teams never faced off last spring — and Murphy quickly sold Stevenson on all that Alabama had to offer. A modern, spacing-centric offense. An immediate role, given the team’s roster turnover. And a clear model to follow, in former stretch-forward
Noah Clowney — the 21st pick in last summer’s NBA Draft — if Stevenson hoped to one day make the league.
Murphy was one of the people Stevenson leaned on when he first got to campus; they’d play putt-putt or darts or NBA2K together, building on the quick relationship they’d established in the summer. And it didn’t matter if Stevenson wanted to work out at 11 p.m. or 6 a.m.; Murphy would always be there.
“I’m a big development guy, being able to be in the gym with you, continuing to help you grow your game,” Murphy says. “(Jarin’s) a kid that wants to be very good.”
And in the Elite Eight vs. Clemson? The fruits of both their labor. The 6-foot-11 Stevenson scored a team-high (and career-best) 19 points, including five made 3-pointers, to down the
Tigers.
“He gave me confidence to come in here,” Stevenson said in Alabama’s postgame locker room, “and he knew that I’d develop.”
Without Murphy, maybe Stevenson isn’t here. And without Stevenson, maybe Alabama isn’t.
And yet …“I loved him, he needed back in, I needed an unbelievable assistant, and it all came together at the same time,” Oats says, “and here we are in the Final Four.”