I have been one of the more outwardly Pitino fanboys, and I thought I would give my reasons why this is a must hire for SJU.
Since Carnesecca retired, I cannot think of any other schools that have gone through as many coaching changes as this one. It is an average of one every four years. And not because of their successful tenure which was noticed by the Big 12 or Big 10 either.
A toxic combination of wrong hire, wrong time, wrong administration, and the wrong side of luck has made SJU, the lone basketball program residing in NYC in a major conference, to surpass laughingstock into an afterthought.
There is no need to go through each coach. We know what they did and didn’t do that led to their demise. We also know past administrations overseeing its flagship program failed miserably as well.
While we may as well repeat this on loop, but the program is at critical mass. How many knockdowns can it take before never getting back up?
Some are worried Pitino will leave the program mired in sanctions.
First of all, with the advent of the NIL, especially now that the universities have control of where the money goes, the NCAA has effectively ended “illegal payouts”.
Secondly, Pitino has done everything right at Iona.
Thirdly, Pitino will have eyes around him in the local and national media who will suddenly find following SJU worthwhile, and many would love to uncover cheating.
Lastly you can add that SJU has missed so many NCAA tournaments, it may as well have been on probation. At least that would have been an excuse for the ineptitude.
The day Pitino sets foot on campus, he is immediately the face of SJU and NYC college basketball. His picture alone in front of MSG accompanied by “Welcome Home Coach” will add adrenaline around here we haven’t see in a long time.
Pitino’s hall of fame credentials are known. He has taken three different schools to the final four, so why not one more big run? Why not us?
This is not to knock on the other candidates. They all appear solid. This is just to hammer home the disparity between Pitino and the rest of the pack.
Of course Pitino does not guarantee glory and a foundation for future and sustained success. No one does. Even machines like Wright built at Villanova has already shown cracks in its foundation.
SJU cannot let this opportunity — which is being placed in its hands — to hire one of the greatest college basketball coaches of all time go. Pitino is by far the closest this program has ever had to a guarantee.