I'm not seeing anything like the numbers you are that determined Tommy to be awful coach. Bad memory so I looked stuff up a couple of times. You got Tommy going to on NIT with the hall. I see 4 post season appearances in 4 years that include a NCAA sweet sixteen. The Michigan team he took over was loaded down with sanctions but he did go to 2 NIT finals, winning one. True, not good enough for Michigan and he was fired from a tough job in a rough league. What he has done at Harvard can be described as great. One of his recruiting classes ranked as the best in Ivy history. I love the Johnnies, only team I root for, but if I had to come up with a Hall coach I liked it would be Louie Orr. I more then liked Louie, I had him down for being a great guy. At the time Amaker went to Michigan I was pissed at him for running out on the Hall. You might want to get your info straight on Tommy and if I got it wrong let me know. If you don't want to bother, thats fine too.Results count. I don't believe Tommy can't coach.Max is 6'7 and that makes it much harder to close out on him. Whoever is on him won't be able to help at all and that will open things up tremendously. If he can shoot off a curl, that makes him much, much more dangerous. 500/584 is absurd. The overwhelming majority of players in D-1 can't do that from the FT line. It is the definition of automatic.
I like hearing that he's an extra hard worker. And this sounds great in theory and I am very much looking forward to seeing him play for us, but how do you answer the critics that say that there are a lot of great shooters that aren't D1 caliber players and that in Hooper's case, he wasn't a factor at Harvard so how will he ever be a Big East level player? Not knocking him just repeating arguments I've heard. And has he actually grown to a legit 6'7" ?
Don't under estimate how awful Tommy Amaker is as a coach.
I am basing it totally on results. 16 years coaching - he made the NCAA 3 times. He was awful at the Hall, taking a team with 3 players that played in the NBA (one still playing) and 2 others that had good overseas career to a 16-15 record and a first round NIT exit. He parlayed that into 6 years of futility at UM. At Harvard he only managed to recruit players who were dismissed for cheating.
My point is I don't trust his opinion on players and I am going to wait until Hooper plays a few games before I judge weather he will make an impact or not at STJ.
Coaches change, both for the better and the worse. My informationI (directly from those affected and people I know and trust) about Amaker when he was at Michigan was that he did some players and high school coaches dirty and wound up in a mess of his own making.