there is definitely excellent seafood in California but it is telling that Maine lobster has won this event in both previous years.
Well, of course it does. It's a lobster event, if it was an oyster event, or a tuna event?. No question Maine has the best lobster. All the top restaurants on the west coast are serving maine lobster. But Cousins is an LA company, albeit started by a pair of transplanted Maine cousins. Started out as a food truck here but now into franchising food trucks nationally and has a brick and mortar restaurant here as well.
There is Pacific tuna, Pacific oysters and even Pacific lobster you can fish for south of central California. The best seafood is local and as fresh from the water as possible. Better yet, caught yourself. That is what I meant. Maine lobster flown into NY is just not as good. Fly it across the country and that goes double.