carmineabbatiello
Well-known member
Was it written in stone on Mount Sinai that Kadary and Mormon can't start/play together? Let's get our best players out there together and see where the chips fall.
The “acquired taste” in question:No argument that he's an acquired taste
I know that Posh was the epitome of a warrior and you had to spend more time telling him to get off the floor than to get on it, so I understand how endearing that is. And I also understand how frustratingly annoying it is that Kadary is not that guy to get on the floor.
Fair, but return on NIL investment for Kadary to date is disappointing, but best to judge over a more substantial period of time I guess.I know that Posh was the epitome of a warrior and you had to spend more time telling him to get off the floor than to get on it, so I understand how endearing that is. And I also understand how frustratingly annoying it is that Kadary is not that guy to get on the floor.
So I offer these stats just to show that Kadary, perhaps underperforming by a large margin, is still producing at a quality level.
Posh last year at sju
10.2 pts 3.9 rebs 4.2 asts 2 stls 2.9 TO
40% fg 23% 3fg
Kadary thru 10 games
10.4 pts 5.2 rebs 4.9 asts 1.4 stls 2.5 TO
46% fg 25% 3fg
If 10 5 5 with a block and a steal and a half were garbage, there would be a lot more garbage.
Is Shaka on the LMF “acquired taste” possibility list?He has a very idiosyncratic approach to the game. There's a ton of old-man-game in him. If you are looking for dunks, threes and highlight-reel plays you are likely to be disappointed. But he is almost invariably productive ways that both do and don't show up in the stat sheet and will do his best (and usually succeed) to deliver in the spots you need him to deliver.
No argument that he's an acquired taste and in fairness his performance has been very up and down so far as SJU. But I think that it will be more up as he settles in and also when league play starts. I guess we'll see.
It's disappointing but far from what people are saying here. We would've gotten blown out against Baylor, lose to Georgia, and New Mexico/K-State would've been a much tougher game.Fair, but return on NIL investment for Kadary to date is disappointing, but best to judge over a more substantial period of time I guess.
that video was tongue in cheek, as you can see in my post on previous page on this thread I clearly appreciate some of what Kadary brings to the team.I know that Posh was the epitome of a warrior and you had to spend more time telling him to get off the floor than to get on it, so I understand how endearing that is. And I also understand how frustratingly annoying it is that Kadary is not that guy to get on the floor.
So I offer these stats just to show that Kadary, perhaps underperforming by a large margin, is still producing at a quality level.
Posh last year at sju
10.2 pts 3.9 rebs 4.2 asts 2 stls 2.9 TO
40% fg 23% 3fg
Kadary thru 10 games
10.4 pts 5.2 rebs 4.9 asts 1.4 stls 2.5 TO
46% fg 25% 3fg
If 10 5 5 with a block and a steal and a half were garbage, there would be a lot more garbage.
We lost to Georgia because of Kadary. We win that game if he was sick that dayIt's disappointing but far from what people are saying here. We would've gotten blown out against Baylor, lose to Georgia, and New Mexico/K-State would've been a much tougher game.
Quite the assumption IMO. Him playing poorly doesnt mean we would have had other guys step up in his absence.We lost to Georgia because of Kadary. We win that game if he was sick that day
I don't believe that at all. The entire team played like garbage.We lost to Georgia because of Kadary. We win that game if he was sick that day
He's on the "empty calories" list with Daniss Jenkins.Is Shaka on the LMF “acquired taste” possibility list?
We lost because the team shot 31% from the field and 10% from 3 point land. Georgia shot 49% and 41%. It was still only a one possession loss.We lost to Georgia because of Kadary. We win that game if he was sick that day
I would not say past time since conference play has not started yet. BUT, I would say we could conceivably be undefeated at this juncture had he played at the excepted level. Maybe expectations were not realistic, or maybe the fit is not quite right. BUT, there has been an obvious and material drop off from his past production. Aside from production though, more concerning is the seeming lack of intensity or urgency, and hard play. Maybe this is just his personality, and not knowing him, maybe this was to be expected. I don't know.Past time for KR to earn his NIL.
With respect this was posted less than 24 hours ago. And FWIW I think Al is a great poster. But I wouldn’t call it taking it personal as much as just defending one our own players.I would not say past time since conference play has not started yet. BUT, I would say we could conceivably be undefeated at this juncture had he played at the excepted level. Maybe expectations were not realistic, or maybe the fit is not quite right. BUT, there has been an obvious and material drop off from his past production. Aside from production though, more concerning is the seeming lack of intensity or urgency, and hard play. Maybe this is just his personality, and not knowing him, maybe this was to be expected. I don't know.
I also don't get why some are seeming to take it personally when the obvious is pointed out: he is not performing as expected. This is not a kid who we all have gotten warm and fuzzy about after 2 or 3 years on the team. He's basically a mercenary, playing semi-pro ball, who has come here for big NIL to do a job. He is probably a great kid, but we certainly as fans can and should hope and expect that he play with energy, pride and to his potential, as demonstrated by past performance. Critiquing his play to date does not equate to calling him out as a bad kid or teammate. It just states the obvious.
In any event, there's lots of season to be played and I hope he plays better than he has. If so, watch out. If not, we'll still have a good season, but won't reach our potential.
Wouldn't have needed another guy to step up. Would have just needed them to be a net zero and not a huge negative.Quite the assumption IMO. Him playing poorly doesnt mean we would have had other guys step up in his absence.
You can say the same about Deivon Smith who went 1-7, Wilcher who went 1-6, Dunlap 0-4, Scott 2-11 from 3pt.Wouldn't have needed another guy to step up. Would have just needed them to be a net zero and not a huge negative.
That wasn't a game we lost by double digits. We were right in it at the end. If we replaced Kadary's 35 mins of 1-8 shooting, 2 Assists, 3 Turnovers with a replacement level player we win that game.
I said on another post that I thought that was harsh, so I agree with that.With respect this was posted less than 24 hours ago. And FWIW I think Al is a great poster. But I wouldn’t call it taking it personal as much as just defending one our own players.
“Richmond is slow, lazy, can't shoot past 10 feet, can't finish at the rim, is a turnover machine, and plays lousy defense. He throws more bad passes than good passes. Other than that he's an all-American candidate to some.”