This isn't about what a game does or doesn't do for Syracuse. The only consideration should be whether or not it helps St. Johns.
And there is no other opponent we can beat, which would be as big a recruiting tool as beating Syracuse at MSG.
Jermaine Lawrence, Whitehead.. all these recruits we're after are considering SU as well. That's not going to change just because they move to the ACC.
But we have to be good enough to be competitive in those games. I'm confident we will be. And the fans will come. Nobody expects it to be all Mets fans when they host the Yankees. Recruits understand there are going to be Syracuse fans at a game at the Garden.
But beating 'Cuse in front of a packed house is the closest thing we can have to Duke hosting a recruit the weekend they play Carolina, or Michigan hosting recruits when they play Ohio State.
You guys are ignoring what a game against Syracuse does for our program.
You are in the "I just do not get it" club! MSG is the redmen's home court. If your idea of having a home court advantage is 15,000 tickets sold on the open market to Syracuse fans, then you failed Marketing 101. Cuse had a NYC metro market wil the Hall, Rutgers and SJ. They traded that market for the closest rival they should now have to NYC......BOSTON! Hopefully, down the road, they do as well as Miami and BC are now doing in both football and basketball!
I don't think it's a home court advantage when we play in front of Cuse crowds. But I'm also realistic. There has been near zero demand for SJU tickets in the last decade. We've been awful. We were 32-70 in conference games during Norm. No one's going to come to watch that. So while it angers me, it doesn't surprise me that Syracuse fans have been overwhelming.
But I think our attendance will improve. We've had a similar situation with UCONN, and especially in the late 90's, their fans flooded the Garden. The Artest/Postell teams negated that advantage pretty well, and we had good crowds for home games and Big East tournament games. But that's because we were competitive.
I think our attendance will improve. If it doesn't, then I would agree with you, we shouldn't schedule Syracuse.
But
if we are good, then playing Syracuse is a huge recruiting tool for us that we shouldn't throw away.