beast of the east
Active member
I would point out that in the 70s and 80s Villanova and BC both had a large percentage of their students who were local and commuted even though there were dorms present. At Nova for certain, and I'm guessing BC also, in that period more than half their students commuted. Back in those days, the distance between St. John's and those schools academically was not as pronounced as it is today. Evidence of that is that many of our alumni from that period have enjoyed tremendous career success, and I would guess that the top 20% of SJU students were academically as qualified as students at Georgetown, BC, or Villanova.austour post=445868 said:NCJohnnie post=445865 said:Beast of the East wrote:
Very fair points, but the point is basketball success catapulted donations AND applications, all improving academic standing.
To a lesser extent, Providence basketball helped do the same for that school.
Agree, and at least in 2010 when my daughter was applying to colleges and we considered and visited PC, it was a far better college than SJU from an academic perspective although nowhere near the other three mentioned.
I would also add that to most of the old fogie posters on this board (myself included) STJ was always a commuter school. The first dorms were not opened until 1999. Commuter's tend to not develop nearly as strong a connection with their university as kids who live their young adult lives on or near their campus, which no doubt has an adverse impact on STJ donations leading to a lower budget for important university spending like basketball coaches.
Providence, I believe, benefitted as an overflow school to BC, Holy Cross, and to some extent Villanova. Good students who were not accepted at those schools were looking for the next best Catholic schools, and Loyola MD, Providence, and Fordham all benefitted.
With new health professions to be offered, specifically nursing and physical therapy, SJU's academic profile will rise due to the more rigorous acceptance requirements for those professions.