Last year, only four games were Q3 or Q4 -- the Georgetown and DePaul games. The Big East got screwed by the committee, plain and simple. The middle class of the league was legitimately tough.
This year, you've got nearly half the league just not being good. Georgetown, Seton Hall, DePaul, Butler, Providence are all A-10 caliber. The away games are thankfully Q2 (except Seton Hall, that is Q3).
It's very damaging for the league to have their two highest budget teams (Georgetown, Villanova) to still be down. Hopefully Cooley gets it going and Nova hires a top coach. That would go a really long way. I hate saying it, but I just don't see how Providence/Butler/Seton Hall/DePaul can consistently compete in the conference with their resources. I'm iffy on Xavier, but they deserve the benefit of the doubt.