I too am not in favor of having any Uconn or Wichita State join the Big East. In Uconn’s case, the idea that the “Uconn big wigs” would be satisfied with playing football in one conference and then basketball in the Big East seems unlikely and temporary at best. Uconn should find a conference to call home and suffer the consequences. Contact the Big 10, ACC, SEC and offer some cash and buy in.
To this point, I don’t see a compelling reason to expand the Big East. The current format is competitive enjoyable. The private and or religious school uniformity seems to work. If there are compelling issues with travel, the East – West format suggested in JO23’s comments seems logical, but perhaps St. Louis and Richmond might be appropriate.
I see your point and I love the Big East as it is too. The new Big East has defintly surpassed any expectations and I would be fine if it stayed like this. But, I just feel if the situation presented itself where UConn wanted to come, and their was an agreement to make it extremly difficult for them to ever leave, you have to take them. For example, if they moved football to FCS or something like that. Than after that I feel the next added school would have to be Wichita State.
Although, I wouldn't expand in the near future unless UConn was coming. In my opinion, schools like Richmond and St. Louis would water down the Big East.
To make it clear what I am trying to say, the only way the Big East should expand and give up on the round robin and private schools is if UConn wants in and wants to stay in and Wichita State comes with them. Nothing else is worth giving up on what we have.