So basically he just rubbed you the wrong way, because you defended Norm until the end. Sorry I keep bringing Norm back up in tandem with Lavin, but considering their respective records here I think it is worth comparing.
I am really starting to wish I had known Norm on a personal level because, he must have been one hell of a guy for people to keep overlooking what was happening on the court.
As far as I am concerned I would back Calipari, Pol Pot, or Charles Manson if they came here and won. That is just me I guess.
It would be foolish of me to deny that I loathe Lavin. But I didn't start out that way and I didn't get there because he was an awful coach. I could live with losing, I have for 40 years now. What really got to me was how pleased he was with himself for being clever enough to fool the rubes into thinking he didn't suck. Which he did.
And I don't consider myself a Norm defender. He was clearly out of his depth and should never have been considered as a candidate for head coach in the Big East. He was - and I still think this today - not as bad as he seemed, considering the circumstances. Did you know that when Norm was offered the job was of his conditions was that SJU hire a dedicated strength and conditioning coach? I'm guessing his hall of fame competitors Jim Boeheim, Rick Pitino, Bob Huggins, and Jay Wright already had one of those. When Lavin was hired one of his conditions was that they give Gene Keady a 250K no show job so he'd have someone to go to Rao's with. It was a whole different world.
What I did was challenge people who attacked Norm. Because much of what people said about him was simply not true. And I still have that impulse. Like even now, when you said earlier in this thread that Lavin deserves credit for playing Hardy and Brownlee his first year I say to myself, well, the year before the 25 extra minutes that went to those two a year later went to Mason Jr, Norm's only senior. Next year those minutes would have had to go somewhere. Look:
(Norm) (Lavin)
DJ 31/29
Horne 28/28
Burrell 20/21
Boothe 25/19/(-6)
Evans 21/12 (-8)
Stith 11/12
Mason Jr 24/0 (-24)
Hardy 22/34 (+12)
Brownlee 18/30 (+12)
Polee 0 /15 (+15)
Mason's minutes went to the JUCOs and Boothe and Evans to Polee. That could be evidence of coaching acumen or it could be what anyone else would have done, even Norm. I suppose Norm could have given those 25 minutes to Cameron Edison, or played DJ and Horne 40 minutes a game but that seems unlikely to me. So I don't see where Lavin is deserving of too much credit.
I consider that more correcting the record than defending Norm. Like when some people give Mark Jackson too much credit as a freshman PG, it's important to note that as an underclassman Mark Jackson was pretty out of control and senior Mike Moses was a pretty good ball player. Because you're entitled to your own opinions, but not your own facts.