St John’s in danger of Closing ?

[quote="Beast of the East" post=396165][quote="Room112" post=396162][quote="Beast of the East" post=396121][quote="Room112" post=396118][quote="jerseyshorejohnny" post=396102][quote="Room112" post=396078][quote="Beast of the East" post=396045][quote="Mike Zaun" post=396032]As a '14 grad I started getting calls immediately after. I'm currently saving for a house and of course paying off SJ so I don't have much to spare, but donated last few times around. They sent me a thank you card with an individualized "at a glance" type thing about the program I graduated from, the year, the degree, etc. which was pretty cool honestly. They tried to call again recently. Once you give em a crumb, they become your best friend! In all seriousness though, I wonder the same as a poster above...why are we in such dire straits compared to your average private school? I thought we would be in better position than many. It's always hard to tell if things are exaggerated for effect or if it really is that bad. I get the sense we are too big a name to close for good...and I hope that's the case. That would be an absolute disaster.[/quote]

Mike, In terms of endowment, we have the second/third best liquid position in the Big East (1. Georgetown, 2/3 Villanova & St. John's) at about $700 million. Bobby G. focused fiscal management deserves all the credit for that. However, in comparison to other more stable schools, or endowment on a per student basis ($69,000 from the article posted) we fall into the at risk category. Although we are ranked high in the Big East in endowment, that is a deceiving number since a school like Villanova without a campaign since 2014, raises $100 million of "we can basically do whatever we want" money.

The reason schools start asking for donations immediately upon graduation is that they wish to create a culture of giving among alumni. Many schools ask for a tiny amount, for example $20.20 for 2020 grads. They publish the % of giving among their class or withing a particular college within the university (e.g. business school, nursing school, etc.) and create a goal of 100% giving. What they hope to engender are increased donations as graduates begin to have career success, and they endeavor to keep their graduates close to them with alumni gatherings and networking. In many schools, the 1, 5, and even 10 year reunions on campus are very well attended. In terms of getting increased requests for donations, I think it's just a well known fact that those who give once are more likely to give again than someone who has never given. Virtually every charitable organization devotes more focus to repeat donors.

Schools like Harvard, have a center for allumni in Manhattan, that frankly once inside, looks like you entered a medieval castle. Villanova opened a center in Manhattan for alumni about 5 years ago. These places often have meeting space, lounges, a bar, maybe even a restaurant, and also cater events that alumni have preferential treatment. These investments are almost certain to increase alumni giving, and probably help the school in all ways.

Almost certainly the goal is to create a relationship with alumni that makes alums feel closely tied to the school, proud of its success, and eager to help the school become bigger and better.

I'm told by those in administration that when St. John's runs events for alumni that are free, they are very well attended. If they charge even a nominal amount, they are not well attended at all. As a school and alumni base, we have a lot of work to do.

After many years of virtual inactivity save for season tix, I've met a lot of great people here on redmen.com and also through R-W. I always give first preference to qualified St. John's grads when hiring, because our strength is in our unity.

In terms of inactivating email addresses, I wonder if schools consider the liability of perhaps having alums appear to be students or administrators long after they have left the school. Most schools appear to have trended towards inactivating email addresses within 1 year of graduation or sooner. It could be a liability to the school to keep them active. It may also be getting pressure from companies that offer steep student discounts, Microsoft is an example whereby MS Office is sharply discounted for students, but I'm not sure.[/quote]

UConn has a NYC alumni chapter, but nothing to the extent you mentioned of what Villanova or Harvard have done. I've actually attended a couple of the events and left unimpressed, certainly nothing to entice me to want to donate.[/quot

Out of curiosity, what were the events you attended ??[/quote]

One event was to welcome new alumni to the city. It was at some bar designated as the official UConn bar of the city I forget. Another event was one of the former UConn women's players who is now in the WNBA speaking about at Organization she is involved with. Both events had about 25 people, who Id say we're in 20s-30s, and both were at pretty standard bars. Nothing crazy.[/quote]

The smartest schools spend a lot of money hiring real talent in development (fund raising) positions. When my kids went to Villanova, the oldest one was only a few weeks into freshman year when they reached out to me as a parent, knew what I did, and had an idea that I could help. They also were very gracious in their approach. I ended up donating there for 7 years, and will again in the future. Boston College on the other hand, with a much larger endowment ($5 billion) made no effort whatsoever to reach me directly while my other kid was there.

It really takes some coordinated campaigns that are well funded to raise money at the college level. The events you attended at UCONN appear to have been unsuccessful, and perhaps either ill conceived or disorganized. Building a strong allegiance from alumni takes years, and there is no good reason why we can't attract more alumni as active supporters of SJU[/quote]

I'll be 100% honest in that my wife and I who are both alums never donated to UConn and really don't plan to. We got our education there but neither of us feel a strong connection to the school. Aside from that, their approach to seeking out donations has always felt like spam calls. I appreciate they do various alumni events like I mentioned in various cities where they have alumni, but as pointed out, never felt they were a success.[/quote]

I don't care if you never donate to UCONN. I do care if you start rooting for them. No room in section 114 for uconn fans[/quote]

Or on this Board ;)
 
[quote="BrookJersey Redmen" post=396863]My two cents:

Commuter school/many if not most of my 1970's classmates worked full or part time while we attended school, that led to not much school spirit. A lot of my classmates (not me) could care less about BB, and frankly the school, except for the piece of paper.

My brother in law founded the TV Club (circa 1970), graduated and had an enormously successful career as a video post-production editor with 13 emmies to his credit many for Sesame Street, but he never gave a nickel. He worked, went to some classes (not interested as a student even though very bright), met his wife and despite my urging neither gave back money. I went to an event with the sister in law when her husband was post humorously inducted into the SJU TV Club Hall of Fame (very impressive list of people in TV from SJU), still no donations. I don't get it.

On a NYC Club, SJU tried that in the 1980's (I believe), all "All College" Club, in the Lincoln Building on 42 Street across from Grand Central Terminal. Went once, it didn't last long is all I remember.[/quote]

Well said. I think being a commuter school for so many years did, and still does, have an impact on school spirit, and in effect, donations. I hope that will change in the future as we have had dorms on campus for several years now. We'll see.
 
[quote="BrookJersey Redmen" post=396863]My two cents:

Commuter school/many if not most of my 1970's classmates worked full or part time while we attended school, that led to not much school spirit. A lot of my classmates (not me) could care less about BB, and frankly the school, except for the piece of paper.

My brother in law founded the TV Club (circa 1970), graduated and had an enormously successful career as a video post-production editor with 13 emmies to his credit many for Sesame Street, but he never gave a nickel. He worked, went to some classes (not interested as a student even though very bright), met his wife and despite my urging neither gave back money. I went to an event with the sister in law when her husband was post humorously inducted into the SJU TV Club Hall of Fame (very impressive list of people in TV from SJU), still no donations. I don't get it.

On a NYC Club, SJU tried that in the 1980's (I believe), all "All College" Club, in the Lincoln Building on 42 Street across from Grand Central Terminal. Went once, it didn't last long is all I remember.[/quote]

Frankly, I think someone who doesn't write a check (of any amount) after being honored by their alma mater says more about them than St. John's

I belonged to that club in the 1980's but didn't think it was all that great.
 
[quote="jerseyshorejohnny" post=396952][quote="BrookJersey Redmen" post=396863]My two cents:

Commuter school/many if not most of my 1970's classmates worked full or part time while we attended school, that led to not much school spirit. A lot of my classmates (not me) could care less about BB, and frankly the school, except for the piece of paper.

My brother in law founded the TV Club (circa 1970), graduated and had an enormously successful career as a video post-production editor with 13 emmies to his credit many for Sesame Street, but he never gave a nickel. He worked, went to some classes (not interested as a student even though very bright), met his wife and despite my urging neither gave back money. I went to an event with the sister in law when her husband was post humorously inducted into the SJU TV Club Hall of Fame (very impressive list of people in TV from SJU), still no donations. I don't get it.

On a NYC Club, SJU tried that in the 1980's (I believe), all "All College" Club, in the Lincoln Building on 42 Street across from Grand Central Terminal. Went once, it didn't last long is all I remember.[/quote]

Frankly, I think someone who doesn't write a check (of any amount) after being honored by their alma mater says more about them than St. John's

No truer words were ever spoken. If you dont want the honour don't accept it, but if you do accept you should be generous to the school. I can never understand such behaviour, just shameful.
 
[quote="jerseyshorejohnny" post=396952][quote="BrookJersey Redmen" post=396863]My two cents:

Commuter school/many if not most of my 1970's classmates worked full or part time while we attended school, that led to not much school spirit. A lot of my classmates (not me) could care less about BB, and frankly the school, except for the piece of paper.

My brother in law founded the TV Club (circa 1970), graduated and had an enormously successful career as a video post-production editor with 13 emmies to his credit many for Sesame Street, but he never gave a nickel. He worked, went to some classes (not interested as a student even though very bright), met his wife and despite my urging neither gave back money. I went to an event with the sister in law when her husband was post humorously inducted into the SJU TV Club Hall of Fame (very impressive list of people in TV from SJU), still no donations. I don't get it.

On a NYC Club, SJU tried that in the 1980's (I believe), all "All College" Club, in the Lincoln Building on 42 Street across from Grand Central Terminal. Went once, it didn't last long is all I remember.[/quote]

Frankly, I think someone who doesn't write a check (of any amount) after being honored by their alma mater says more about them than St. John's

I belonged to that club in the 1980's but didn't think it was all that great.[/quote]

I think part of the problem with older a one night not donating is that because most of us went straight to work after school and paid tuition out of pocket from part time jobs and summer jobs, we always thought that we were carrying the whole burden. We didn't think for a second that are tuition was kept auto ficially very low through low Paid employees and donations from alumni who graduated before us. We may have gotten book lowest cost private education in a major city in all the world at least in America. When I began thinking in those terms it was easier to give back .
 
Back to the topic at hand, I have given generously to the school over the years and I will continue to do so, and encourage other alums to as well. I will increase what I give if this horrible story proves to be true, but I hope and pray that this story has no truth to it and St. John's University survives the pandemic and thrives. While I love this school I must say it holds a special place in the annals of New York City, going all the way back to its founding in Brooklyn in 1870. Through the years St. John's University served an underserved community and was the choice for many first-in-their-family, to attend a college or university. Certainly it was that way for me in my immediate family. Mom had to goods to go to college but not the money or the family guidance (her mom and dad were immigrants off the boat trying to make a living and feed 5 mouths). My dad was a proud NYC firefighter. He was so proud of me graduating from college as he had to go back to Erasmus Hall HS to get his GED after joining the Army for WWII. Many NYC students could afford the relatively reasonable tuition, and back in the early days minority students were more welcomed at St. John's than at the more prestigious Columbia and NYU.

I am very proud of St. John's and I wear my loyalty to the school on my sleeve, as all of my family and close friends know (and remind me from time to time).

Please stay the course, and please St. John's University survive and thrive for another 150 years and beyond.

Those that can, please give generously to Alma Mater.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top