Below is the email I just sent to Father Shanley with a copy to the athletic department. I entitled it "Betrayed Season Ticket Holder and Fan."
Dear Father Shanley,
My name is Will Reiss. By way of background, my Grandfather, Mom and her three siblings all attended SJU. While I didn't attend SJU myself, I have been a diehard fan for 40 years (since I was eight-years-old).
When people ask me why I'm such a big fan given that I didn't attend the school, I tell them it's because my love of the university is in my blood passed down from two generations. I was raised to be a SJU fan, and watching and attending games has provided countless bonding moments with my Dan and Uncle (like me, my Dad did not attend SJU but he is a diehard fan).
I am as passionate a SJU fan as they come and I bleed red and white despite never having attended the university. For instance, I proudly display a large SJU flag in front of my home, much to my wife's chagrin. My Uncle, Dad and I text incessantly about the program and anybody who knows me even casually knows my passion for the program. For better or for worse, being a Red Storm fan has become a large part of my identity as a person.
Despite living in NJ, it had always been my dream to be a season ticket holder. For well over a decade I have held season tickets (two seats) for all games. For the prior two decades, I purchased various plans and individual seats. As I'm sure you'll agree, the product was frequently poor and the fan base was apathetic to put it nicely. Nonetheless, I remained steadfast and loyal, purchasing season tickets year in and year out at significant expense. No matter how bad the team, how apathetic the fan base and how empty the arena, I never missed a game, traveling two hours each way from my home in NJ (bus to train to bus). During the COVID year, I purchased season tickets even though I didn't feel comfortable attending the games in-person just so I could maintain my season tickets. Those tickets mean the world to me.
As you can imagine, I felt a sense of shock and betrayal after receiving the recent correspondence suggesting that I may lose my seats based on the University's "reallocation initiative." I get it that this is a business and that money is critical, particularly in the NIL era. But this is no way to treat your loyal fans. Surely there are ways to encourage donations and raise money without penalizing the program's most loyal supporters.
And respectfully, I found the correspondence to be in particularly bad taste given that, with a few minor exceptions, this year is the first real hint of prosperity we've had in nearly 30 years. Yet, for fans like myself who have remained loyal (in both wallet and spirit), the school is threatening to take away or diminish our seats at the first sign of progress.
I strongly urge you to reconsider your policy, which I think is not only a slight to your most loyal fan base, but will likely result in minimal if any financial gain. To the contrary, I suspect many will share my reaction which may well result in a backlash against the program.
I also request that you please forward this email to Mr. Kull. While I don't think it's productive for me to engage in threats or ultimatums, particularly over something that means so much to me, I can't imagine how I could remain a fan, no less a season ticket holder, if the University follows through on its threat to take away or diminish my season tickets in the coming years.
-Will