we are sju
Active member
72 i get your concern but i have also seen my fair share of kids who either came into my classroom or my track practices and turned their crummy a** attitudes around. I defer to Lavins appraisal. If he is good with it so am I.
I am all for giving young people second and third chances. I am not sure some here, desperate for an edge to win a game or two, understand the depth of the issue with this young man. Had it not been for Lavin's intervention last year, coach Dunlap was ready to dismiss him from the team......while Lavin was recovering from cancer surgery! Had we not had just 6 new players to compete in a brutal Big East, he would have been gone. The issue of his "maturity" was evident when Lav returned and was so bad that he was suspended...twice! I personally do NOT trust Lavin's judgment in this case since it took "other" staff to "convince" him of the damage this kid was doing. From what I heard, his erratic behavior become so bad that it destroyed his own "game" as the past month or so is witness.
Someone I know has a child attending SJ who lives in the dorms. From what they told their dad after this suspension was that he is no better to his fellow students. He is not practicing, not interacting in team activities and was given a workout schedule. Like a former member of the women's team who put her problems on others, I doubt those workouts will improve his "attitude".
I have not been a fan of his game since early in the season when I heard he was a problem. When that translated into a one man show in games, it hardened my opinion even more.
Does it say something to you when we recruit 7 top 100 kids and the entire offense is being dictated by one player? Last year Nurideen Lindsey thought he should be that player, and this year it was Harrison. You cut your losses with players with that frame of mind and replace them ASAP.
As for options, this story is less than a week old. By the April signing period his options will become clearer if we sign RJ. Trust me, if that happens, he is gone!
So basically recruit a 19 year old kid and if you can't reach him dump him and move on? I understand that college sports is a buisness, but your post basically throws support behind the real buisnessmen in this deal the University and coaches while basically treating the players like cattle. Lavin recruited Harrison and Nuri and you make it like Harrison some how let Lavin down? If Harrison is a pain, and by all accounts he is, Lavin is culpable in this and takes a hit as well. In this situation he is not some sort of sympathetic figure. And by the way whose fault was it that Nuri left, Harrison was a pain and we only had 5 other scholarship players?
I hope this can get worked out, but if it doesn't it is really convenient to blame Harrison while making Lavin out to be some kind of victim.
No offense, but when does personal responsbility kick in, instead of spreading out culpability on Lavin for recruiting or somehow mismanaging a player . From what I understand Harrison is a very troubled guy who may not just need a change in attitude, but medical treatment. However, while I think it would be great if the university gets him help, whether therapy, or psychiatric help, the mere expression that he wants to stay at St. John's shouldn't be seen as something wonderful What would be a wonderful first step is for harrison to admit he has disrespected coaches and teammates, and that he owes a huge apology to them. Second he must not just promise not to do this again, but get the help he needs to deal with anger issues, and begin to respect authority figures in his life (coaches, teachers, bosses, etc). Third he must be aware that the only proofe of this change is to avoid at all costs these outbursts and negative attitude that is destroying his collegiate tenure. The first steps in my opinion are not enough. A tough guy doesn't curse his coaches and teammates out, he publicly acknowledges what an ass he has been, and beings to take corrective action
He was never arrested, has not been involved in any fights with teamates, students or coaches and from what we understand is in good academic standing. Yet your understanding is he may need some sort of "psychiatric or medical treattment" ? Where may I ask are you getting that info from? Better yet when Ron Artest a player who not only needed help, but to his credit seeked it out(though I don't think it has taken hold) was here were you advocating throwing him off the team?
Who said he was arrested or got in a fight? He was disruptive and over the top disrespectful. This is acceptable because he didn't punch anyone? He was wrong and I for one agree that an apology and acknowledgement and recognition of being the cause of the situation goes a long way in my mind. If he needs help get help. Why defend his actions?
He never did. He is saying that the medical treatment comment was absurd and it is
How do you know what help he needs or doesn't? I hope Harrison straightens himself out but if you don't think the lack of self control he has to get to this point isn't a legitimate problem you're wrong.
Ok, since none of us know what he needs or doesn't why would someone offer up psychiatric help? Evidently the kid is a pain and I am not disputing that. Again from what all of us have seen his on court, his antics are no worse than what Bobby Hurley was doing at Duke.