Let me preface this and say I like Amir, I think he is a stand up kid!! But i would live to see him + - breakdowns, he makes some horrible basketball decisions that cost us big time! I don't see Amir ever really Playing at a high big east level, yes he is athletic but all the kids running and jumping can't hide the fact that he has no clue on the court....
You are reducing this kid's career to one or to plays he made at the end in the spotlight (only as a soph). Out of all the players on this squad, I think Amir has the second highest bball IQ behind Harrison. I think he would do really well in a structured half court system with screens, back-door cuts, ball movement, proper spacing, etc. We don't have that here...at least not last year. Lavin's rolled some of the nation's best athletes with very little skill and the did not play intelligently.
What in Garrett's play exhibited high basketball IQ? His ability to cover the corner's in a zone? Or maybe all those wide open three's our opponent's got were Garrett on the fly calculating the shooter's 3 pt % and letting him shoot? Maybe it was out porous interior defense, and Garrett deciding to sucker his man into getting his shot blocked by Obekpa? I really didn't see what you claim in Garrett's game. Maybe your right, but in his case it would be like a high IQ person performing poorly on exams.
The only thing I can say about your reference to Harrison, is I wish he played for Rutgers, so I could see a tape of his response when a ball got fired at his head.