Amir Garrett Leaving St. John's

Let's agree to disagree!!! I don't see his basketball skills increasing at all.... He is a undersized 4 with very limited room for growth! Good athlete and thats aboutbit to me....

I liked Amir and really dont understand all the criticism. It sounds like some of you are just trying to justify in your own mind that his leaving wont hurt the team. Well I think it will hurt. I just hope they can make up for it with another recruit or better play.
 
No I liked Amir and I can appreciate his work ethic but he us no more than a 10 min a game sub! Can't shoot it, can't handle it, not a great feel for the game and way too many mistakes! His minutes will be picked up easily
 
Just for your information, Garrett came out of Findlay Prep, in las vegas. There is no real school, no dorms. Findlay, a car dealer, is a rich UNLV fan who started up this faux school to funnel players to the rebels. The team is loaded with talent and their alums are all over - Oregon, Arizona, Ohio Stat, Texas, SD ST., etc
Some have done well, some less so. They take some classes in a Henderson private school, live in some houses that Findlay owns, but spend most of their time on the road playing other powerhouse preps. The only school in the vegas valley that will play them is Bishop Gorman, also a powerhouse, but a real school with solid academics. I think some of the Findlay kids are overated because the loaded roster makes everyone look good, and the kids are generally older than normal hs seniors. I have no idea how they are accredited, but this is Nevada. Have a lucky day.
 
Let me preface this and say I like Amir, I think he is a stand up kid!! But i would live to see him + - breakdowns, he makes some horrible basketball decisions that cost us big time! I don't see Amir ever really Playing at a high big east level, yes he is athletic but all the kids running and jumping can't hide the fact that he has no clue on the court....

You are reducing this kid's career to one or to plays he made at the end in the spotlight (only as a soph). Out of all the players on this squad, I think Amir has the second highest bball IQ behind Harrison. I think he would do really well in a structured half court system with screens, back-door cuts, ball movement, proper spacing, etc. We don't have that here...at least not last year. Lavin's rolled some of the nation's best athletes with very little skill and the did not play intelligently.

What in Garrett's play exhibited high basketball IQ? His ability to cover the corner's in a zone? Or maybe all those wide open three's our opponent's got were Garrett on the fly calculating the shooter's 3 pt % and letting him shoot? Maybe it was out porous interior defense, and Garrett deciding to sucker his man into getting his shot blocked by Obekpa? I really didn't see what you claim in Garrett's game. Maybe your right, but in his case it would be like a high IQ person performing poorly on exams.

The only thing I can say about your reference to Harrison, is I wish he played for Rutgers, so I could see a tape of his response when a ball got fired at his head.
 
So talented...He had no chance of getting into the NBA. Yet he got drafted in MLB. Time to pursue one of your dreams there kid
 
@Kieran_Lynch: Sam Sealy announced through Twitter that he will transfer from St. John's. #stjbb

Didn't know where to park this.
 
No disrespect to a nice young man. I met and chatted with his family at Midnight Madness and they all seemed like wonderful people. But I didn't know that walk-ons announced their transfer.
 
Let's agree to disagree!!! I don't see his basketball skills increasing at all.... He is a undersized 4 with very limited room for growth! Good athlete and thats aboutbit to me....

I liked Amir and really dont understand all the criticism. It sounds like some of you are just trying to justify in your own mind that his leaving wont hurt the team. Well I think it will hurt. I just hope they can make up for it with another recruit or better play.

Pretty much agree with Guru Best of luck to him
 
Let me preface this and say I like Amir, I think he is a stand up kid!! But i would live to see him + - breakdowns, he makes some horrible basketball decisions that cost us big time! I don't see Amir ever really Playing at a high big east level, yes he is athletic but all the kids running and jumping can't hide the fact that he has no clue on the court....

You are reducing this kid's career to one or to plays he made at the end in the spotlight (only as a soph). Out of all the players on this squad, I think Amir has the second highest bball IQ behind Harrison. I think he would do really well in a structured half court system with screens, back-door cuts, ball movement, proper spacing, etc. We don't have that here...at least not last year. Lavin's rolled some of the nation's best athletes with very little skill and the did not play intelligently.

What in Garrett's play exhibited high basketball IQ? His ability to cover the corner's in a zone? Or maybe all those wide open three's our opponent's got were Garrett on the fly calculating the shooter's 3 pt % and letting him shoot? Maybe it was out porous interior defense, and Garrett deciding to sucker his man into getting his shot blocked by Obekpa? I really didn't see what you claim in Garrett's game. Maybe your right, but in his case it would be like a high IQ person performing poorly on exams.

The only thing I can say about your reference to Harrison, is I wish he played for Rutgers, so I could see a tape of his response when a ball got fired at his head.

.Now that's funny
 
No disrespect to a nice young man. I met and chatted with his family at Midnight Madness and they all seemed like wonderful people. But I didn't know that walk-ons announced their transfer.

I hope this doesn't discourage other walk ons from trying out for the team. This could set the program back years. If Lavin can't keep walk ons, I think he needs to go :-D Good luck Sam!. Thanks for all your hard work the last 2 years.!
 
@Kieran_Lynch: Sam Sealy announced through Twitter that he will transfer from St. John's. #stjbb

Didn't know where to park this.

Walk ons in most programs have one basic role - to be tough practice players who push the scholarships players hard in practice. Occasionally, a tiny few can see daylight in games. Lipscomb was a great example this year - it's like scaling the heights for a walk on, and in a lot different way than Phil Missere (who we all loved but it was more by circumstance that he got a shot).

Neatly all D1 walk ons could play alot at D2 or D3, and apparently that's what Sealy has chosen for the rest of his career. Good luck to him!
 
didnt he have a scholarship? does this mean we have one more scholarship to give?


No, he was a walk on.

http://zagsblog.com/articles/former-st-johns-walk-on-one-of-the-luckiest-guys-in-america/

i guess i confused which walk on had received a scholarship from lavin, just saying hes a walk on doesnt mean he didnt have a scholarship.

Actually that's exactly what it means to be a walk on. The year Jamal was on scholarship he was not considered a walk on.
........ from Wikipedia:
"The term walk-on is used in sports, particularly American college athletics, to describe an athlete who becomes part of a team without being actively recruited beforehand or awarded an athletic scholarship. This results in the differentiation between "walk-on" players and "scholarship" players"
 
No disrespect to a nice young man. I met and chatted with his family at Midnight Madness and they all seemed like wonderful people. But I didn't know that walk-ons announced their transfer.

LMAO!!!
What's next? Tweets from the student, formerly known as Flagboy, about his beer preferences, post college?
 
No disrespect to a nice young man. I met and chatted with his family at Midnight Madness and they all seemed like wonderful people. But I didn't know that walk-ons announced their transfer.

LMAO!!!
What's next? Tweets from the student, formerly known as Flagboy, about his beer preferences, post college?

So you're saying that you're not interested in what flag boy is up to?
 
I didn't know that walk-ons announced their transfer.

He didn't "announce" his transfer. He tweeted that he was going to his transfer, it's not quite the same thing. It was Kieran Lynch who decided that he "announced" his transfer. Evidently to journalism major and Editor in Chief of the Torch Lynch Twitter is the same as the AP wire and reading the internets comprises investigative journalism.

Here's Sealy's tweet to his 283 Twitter followers: "After a long thought process I have decided to transfer from St.Johns." Hey Sam, get over yourself! Clearly he's an ego maniac and we're lucky he's leaving, he was probably a cancer in the locker room.

Would type more (I know you love long posts) but have to go see if the Torch has picked up any breaking news about the FH scandal from Rob Wile's My Space timeline.
 
It reads like an "announcement."

Uh huh, and right after that he announced that he was at the food court at the mall and then he had a special premiere showing of his sandwich on Instagram.

Bunch of middle aged men breathlessly parsing some kid's twitter feed. I'm embarrassed for you.
 
Back
Top