All-time SJU transfer in vs. out - who wins?

[RedStormNC]

I saw this elsewhere and thought this group might have fun discussing and kill some time until next game.

Pick your starting 5 transfer team who came into SJU, then pick talented 5 who left program and played at another school.

Which group wins the game?

 

 

[L J S A]

Do juco transfers count?

 

[RedStormNC]

Sure, go for it! grad transfer too.

 

[monte]

I can't get beyond Roshown McLeod 

 

[Las Vegan]

Can anyone name this transfer out?
He was a very highly rated recruit who came to St. John's, played frosh ball and, without much fanfare, transfered to the TCU Horned Frogs.

 

[monte]

Can anyone name this transfer out?
He was a very highly rated recruit who came to St. John's, played frosh ball and, without much fanfare, transfered to the TCU Horned Frogs.

Was gonna say Elander Lewis but think he played more than 1 year 
 

 

[Las Vegan]

Clue: he was a Frank Mulzoff recruit

 

[espken]

Bill Bozeat 

 

[Ray Morgan]

Bill Bozeat 

He looked really good in the freshman games. I don't think he developed much after he trsansferred.
 

 

[GardenCity62]

I'm going to eliminate juncos because transfers from SJU to judo would be extremely rare and SJU had many jucos transfer  in. I couldn't come up with any front court players worthy of all time status but a backcourt of Kevin Loughary and Reggie Carter would rank with any SJU backcourt.

 

[L J S A]

I'm going to eliminate juncos because transfers from SJU to judo would be extremely rare and SJU had many jucos transfer  in. I couldn't come up with any front court players worthy of all time status but a backcourt of Kevin Loughary and Reggie Carter would rank with any SJU backcourt.

Ron Rowan
Lamont Middleton
Matt Brust
Marvin Clark
Justin Simon
Durand Johnson
Nyiwe
Jeff Allen



Roshown McLeod
Elijah Ingram
LJ Figueroa
Quincy Roberts


Tariq Owens, Mikey Dixon, Max Hooper, and David Caraher can play for both teams.

 

 

[Alumni Hall]

Elander Lewis went to VCU

 

[Alumni Hall]

Bob Kelly
Mike Moses
Bernard Rencher


Ty Owens

 

[Amaseinyourface]

CHRISTIAN JONES!!

 

[MarkRedman]

If you count JUCOS, Walter Berry is #1 and everyone else can fight for #2

 

[redmanwest]

Incomings would win hands down.

 

[espken]

I'll take five San Jacinto (Jucos) against the field:

Walter Berry
Billy Goodwin
Boo Harvey
Michael Porter
Tom Weadock (his job is to rebound and rebound only)

 

[redmanwest]

There are a lot of transfer guards who could fill this role, but Reggie Carter MUST be one of them.

 

[espken]

Reggie is an all-timer, clutch like Boo Harvey.

Junior year - game winner against Duke on Black Sunday, and buzzer beater at Georgetown his senior year.

 

[beast of the east]