I know that everyone hates Lavin on this board for, well, reasons I guess, but the fact is we've made the tournament 2 times in 15 years and both were under Lavin.
Plus, I don't care how bare your cabinet is when you take over as coach, 1 big east win is unacceptable. To give you an example of how futile that performance is Kevin Clark also got 1 Big East win.
Here is Kevin Clark's cabinet when he got the win
Showtime Daryll Hill (as a freshman)
Tyler Jones
Andre Stanley
Kyle Cuff
Curtis Johnson
Those were his players on scholarship. But, don't worry he had Phil Missere as instant offense off the bench (in reality CuJo was probably the guy that came off the bench vs Gtown, I don't remember).
The point is no excuses. It's year three, Mullin has to make the NIT and have prospects on the NCAA the following year, if not we are looking at Brian Mahoney, a nice story, a true Johnny, but not a head coach.
To further your point, Stanley was actually a walk-on as well but he earned a scholarship which I totally respect. However I would point out one huge difference and that being that those guys were seniors with the exception of Jones and they had played together for a long time. Are we gonna argue who left the program in worse shape Jarvi or Lavin? Notwithstanding Keita and Pittsburgh the Jarvis regime was disastrous but the cupboard was truly gone in the wake of Lavin. Lavin did some good things, Jarvis did some good things. But in the end both screwed us over.
Regardless, no doubt about it, the team needs to produce this season to show real progress.
Misere was a starter on that team. Stanley never received a scholarship (although they were going to give him one) because his financial aid package covered all true costs (including some incidentals) some of which he wouldn't have gotten through his scholarship. This was changed this year by the NCAA where the scholarship now covers "the true" costs.