"The reason for his redshirt is also irrelevant, as your contention was that nobody redshirts in the NIL era and then implied it was because Maker wasn’t good."
My contention is that 4 star players don't need to redshirt to get more playing time because all they need to do is transfer. And, yes, Vince is better right now. Glad you finally agree.
Both Maker and Vince need intense development but in the NIL era there are no guarantees that players buy into the lesson plan.
Vince rushes and forces everything because he is eager to make up for lost time.
If he starts playing more cerebral ball he will be fine at this level.....rather than playing for Iona. Maker is very mechanical and needs better conditioning.
Just hope they stay long enough to meet your expectations.