pistol pete vs st johns

First thoughts on what would have happened if Lew Alcindor choose St. John's is that for one year we would have had the best JV team in the nation and then would have won 3 national championships. But then i remember Lou C was the coach and probably would have made Lew stickly a high post passer and we probably would have had the best JV team in the nation and then gone to 3 NITs.

In his first year, Alcindor would have played for the freshman team (as he did at UCLA).
Hence my saying we would have the best JV team, at least they were called JV teams in my freshman year of 72'73. If I recall Lou had quite a few sophs on JV one of whom my 2nd year was Randy Graham a transfer from syracuse.
 
First thoughts on what would have happened if Lew Alcindor choose St. John's is that for one year we would have had the best JV team in the nation and then would have won 3 national championships. But then i remember Lou C was the coach and probably would have made Lew stickly a high post passer and we probably would have had the best JV team in the nation and then gone to 3 NITs.

In his first year, Alcindor would have played for the freshman team (as he did at UCLA).
Hence my saying we would have the best JV team, at least they were called JV teams in my freshman year of 72'73. If I recall Lou had quite a few sophs on JV one of whom my 2nd year was Randy Graham a transfer from syracuse.

Freshman teams were for freshmen; it was the only level they could play on at the time, and many or most were scholarship players. Junior varsity teams were primarily for sophs who weren't ready (or talented enough) to move up to the varsity. If I remember correctly (and I'm not saying I am), they weren't scholarship players, although there might have been an exception or two. It was almost an invisible level of play.
 
If not for his unjust banishment from the NBA which only ended after a law suit, Connie Hawkins would have shown us all much of Dr J's repertoire long before the good Dr. made it visible

While I've heard similar sentiments before, I have to respectfully disagree Fuchsia. While The Hawk was a great player in his own right in his injury shortened career, but he did not possess the aerodynamics(for lack of a better word) nor the all around game that Doc eventually developed.

Monte, you may be unaware that in 1960 or 1961 Iowa was the number one ranked team in the country, led by none other than Don Nelson. Hawkins was on the freshman team, and they played a scrimmage against the varsity that drew great fanfare. It soon became more than a scrimmage, and the freshmen, led by Hawkins, domianted the varsity squad and won the game.

Another legendary game was vs. Wilt Chamberlain in the Rucker league. Chamberlain had averaged 50 ppg and was regarded as an aboslute monster. Hawkins already banned, but had a spectacular schoolyard legend. Pros, even Chamberlain claiber would actually have to prove themselves on the asphalt against some of the toughest players in the city. Early in the game, Hawkins drove right at Chamberlain who went up to contest the shot. Hawkins kept going up and hook-dunked over Chamberlain, something no one had ever seen before. The game had to be stopped as fans went crazy and celebrated on and off the court.

Off course, as the story goes, Chamberlain regrouped, blocked ever single shot that went up, catching some in mid year - goaltending wasn't called because it was schoolyard and Chamberlain was in a rage. He caught teammates shots and slammed them home. Chamberlain's team won by about 80, but Hawkins legend was set.
 
If not for his unjust banishment from the NBA which only ended after a law suit, Connie Hawkins would have shown us all much of Dr J's repertoire long before the good Dr. made it visible

While I've heard similar sentiments before, I have to respectfully disagree Fuchsia. While The Hawk was a great player in his own right in his injury shortened career, but he did not possess the aerodynamics(for lack of a better word) nor the all around game that Doc eventually developed.

Monte, you may be unaware that in 1960 or 1961 Iowa was the number one ranked team in the country, led by none other than Don Nelson. Hawkins was on the freshman team, and they played a scrimmage against the varsity that drew great fanfare. It soon became more than a scrimmage, and the freshmen, led by Hawkins, domianted the varsity squad and won the game.

Another legendary game was vs. Wilt Chamberlain in the Rucker league. Chamberlain had averaged 50 ppg and was regarded as an aboslute monster. Hawkins already banned, but had a spectacular schoolyard legend. Pros, even Chamberlain claiber would actually have to prove themselves on the asphalt against some of the toughest players in the city. Early in the game, Hawkins drove right at Chamberlain who went up to contest the shot. Hawkins kept going up and hook-dunked over Chamberlain, something no one had ever seen before. The game had to be stopped as fans went crazy and celebrated on and off the court.

Off course, as the story goes, Chamberlain regrouped, blocked ever single shot that went up, catching some in mid year - goaltending wasn't called because it was schoolyard and Chamberlain was in a rage. He caught teammates shots and slammed them home. Chamberlain's team won by about 80, but Hawkins legend was set.

The Hawk was no doubt a legend, unfortunately his injuries shortened what looked to be a great career. I meant my comment not as a knock on the Hawk, but IMO he did not have the kind of athleticism nor all around game that the Doc had. The Hawk's game was more about power, Doc was more about finesse. Both had huge hands which allowed them to control the ball extremely well around the hoop. In fairness, I watched a lot more of Dr. J than the Hawk. If I were starting a team, I would have been glad to have either(with the edge to Doc) as my 1st pick.
 
[A this juncture, the only one who knows for certain what occured in 1965 is Jabbar. The other mystery is did SJU have a chance to get Alcindor after his first year at UCLA, when he considered transferring. One of the posters a while back remembered seeing Alcindor visiting campus during the summer of 1966. It might have just been a casual visit, but if Louie turned him down, now that would be a story.

quote="Class of 72" post=47777]
Pistol Pete have no idea.


As regards Alcindor pure bs. Alcindor published an autobiography in the 1970s ,Seem that Wilt took him to get his greens while he was still in high school and that was the end of any consideration of a Cathollc College.

It been a long time and I'm not sure if it's a auto or just a biography. but I remember it was an interesting read.

From what I've read and heard, Lew's (Kareem's) decision to go to UCLA had a lot more to do than just Coach Lapchick's retirement. It was the revolutionary '60s, and at the time St.John's was deeply rooted in the '50s. (Remember the academic strike in the 1964-65 school year that turned out to be a huge embarrassment to our university? I do; I lost two of the best professors I ever had.) Once he visited UCLA, don't think we ever had a chance with landing him.

redken, Lew was a senior at Power in 1964 and graduated in 1965. Woodstock was 3 years later and even then, Lew had been grounded in Jazz by his dad Ferdinand and was not into the new music and emerging youth culture. He was a quiet, introverted kid and not a free spirit like Bill Walton who followed him at UCLA. He grew up Roman Catholic and did not convert to the Muslim faith until 1968, his junior season at UCLA.
His parents were eager to send him to a Catholic college and wanted to watch him play just a few miles from their St. Albans home in Queens. Lew had a very long commute to Harlem to play at Power and playing for coach Lapchick at Alumni Hall would have been a home coming of sorts.
UCLA had nowhere the tradition or history St. John's had in the early 60's and Lew was St. John's to lose and he did not want to play for an inexperienced assistant named Lou Carnesecca.
BTW, as a teen Lew used to jog miles along the Queens portion of the Belt Parkway during the summer months. He and his father loved the idea of playing for Joe and at the time the huge Alumni Hall just 15 minutes from home. I know this from an old friend who grew up near the Alcindors.

P.S. Coach Lapchick, although forced to retire, was in failing health when Lew was a senior at Power and it is unlikely he would have coached much longer even if SJ waived the mandatory retirement age. Age discrimination was alive and well in the 60's.

For starters, I'm well aware of Lew's history at Power Memorial; I attended Mount St. Michael and watched him crush us in his soph and junior years. But by the time it came for Lew to make his choice between St. John's and UCLA (when I was an SJU frosh), the '60s "revolution" was well into play and coupled with Coach Lapchick's forced retirement coming to pass, Lew's choice to opt for UCLA was easier to make: the super-conservative Catholic university (because that's what it was) with the inexperienced new head coach vs. the free-spirited, Wooden-coached UCLA. Lew may well have liked jogging along the Belt Parkway, but I don't think that entered his mind when making a decision about where he would spend his college years (would you?). Bottom line: it's water under the bridge, spilled milk, etc. ... another one -- albeit the biggest one -- that got away.

Seems like only yesterday redken, doesn't it? LOL!
I remember 1964 as if it were yesterday. It was the British invasion, the Beatles, Dave Clark Five, Zombies, etc. The Beach Boys and Jan and Dean were the California L.A. Sound but the San Fransico bands were just taking off like the Jefferson Airplane, Moby Grape and the Dead. Lew was not into any of the early 60's bubble gum scene. He was into JAZZ.
The early Wooden teams were anything but "free-spirited". Wooden was a strict disciplinarian back then and was the most gifted "teacher" the game has ever known.
Yes, St. John's was very conservative back then, but so was Notre Dame, Georgetown and Villanova. Lew's parents were conservative Catholics and wanted him to attend a Cathloic college. Like many kids that attended parochial schools back then I am sure Lew resented and pushed back. I cannot say it had anything to do with his decision.
I think the fact that UCLA had just won its 2nd NCAA Championship had much more to do with it. Prior to 1963, UCLA was a west-coast school with an average winning record playing in a gym no bigger than Alumnj Hall, Pauley was in the planning stages and all the press focused on the eastern schools. Even average St. John' s team's in the late 50's got more press than UCLA or any of the pre-PAC 10 schools.
Personally, I think the exposure to a "professor-like" coach that had just won his second national title and meeting Walt Hazzard, Gail Goodrich, etc. tipped his decision in UCLA's favor.
I recall my good friend telling me his dad was not happy about his decision but, in the end, it changed the course of college basketball history. One can only imagine what St. John's and NYC college basketball would have been like had his father over-ruled the decision.[/quote]
 
Giant Steps, Alcindor and Peter Knobler 1983!

We may have lost out on Alcindor, but we did get Tom Weadock.
LOL Thought it was Wheatcock though. Didn't Lou play him over BC transfer Paul Berwanger if I remember correctly?
 
Giant Steps, Alcindor and Peter Knobler 1983!

We may have lost out on Alcindor, but we did get Tom Weadock.
LOL Thought it was Wheatcock though. Didn't Lou play him over BC transfer Paul Berwanger if I remember correctly?

I think Berwanger came slightly later. He was a transfer, and his claim to our fame was that he actually shrunk 2 inches from freshman to senior due to a disk problem (6'9 to 6'7). I actually liked his game.

Speaking of short centers, we DID recruit the most celebrated center ever (by the Long Island Press) in Wayne McKoy. His biggest problem (aside from attitude allegedly) was that he stopped growing in the 7th grade. The Press reported his exploits from about age 10.
 
Back to the main topic. The Maravich book mentioned initially on this thread was not availalbe for my kindle, so I bought Pistol Pete. GREAT BOOK so far, and it chronicles not only Pete's life, but that of his father, Press Maravich, who was one of the great innovators in transforming basketball to the modern game. Along with being on the roster of an NBA team in its fledgling season, he literally wrote the book on college recruiting, publishing a book that is still the bible on how to recruit and judge talent. The same principals designed by PRess are used today. Great book for any student of the game.
 
I need help on this one. I used to play Sunday night pickup ball at OLV in Floral Park, with guys like Hank Cluess, Pete LaMantia, on occasion George Bruns, and once in a while Richie Lyons, and many other ex college stars (I was definitely a scrub in that group). LaMantia once mentioned that he held Maravich to 16 points, or so I thought he had said. Either I had misheard or Maravich scored only 16 against LaMantia, and 37 against everyone else on St Johns.

BTW, LaMantia was the best dead eye shooter I ever saw on a local court, bottom of the net nearly all the time from 30 feet and in, even at age 50 or so. Even at that age, the old guard of players would usually win the FP outdoor summer league against kids 30 years their junior.
 
I need help on this one. I used to play Sunday night pickup ball at OLV in Floral Park, with guys like Hank Cluess, Pete LaMantia, on occasion George Bruns, and once in a while Richie Lyons, and many other ex college stars (I was definitely a scrub in that group). LaMantia once mentioned that he held Maravich to 16 points, or so I thought he had said. Either I had misheard or Maravich scored only 16 against LaMantia, and 37 against everyone else on St Johns.

BTW, LaMantia was the best dead eye shooter I ever saw on a local court, bottom of the net nearly all the time from 30 feet and in, even at age 50 or so. Even at that age, the old guard of players would usually win the FP outdoor summer league against kids 30 years their junior.[/quote

I remember following those guys in the box scores posted in the Long Isand Press when they played in the LI Press League. It seemed they all scored in the 20's or more and the scores were in the 135 range, or so it seems to me in my old memory. It seems they didn't play much defense but they were exciting games.
 
Back
Top