Nostalgia: red.fans edition

One of my favorites was the alumni hall regular season finale vs. I think providence in '85. I was nine at the time and we had season tix up in the old red seats. (Or maybe blue?). After the final buzzer no one wanted to leave because despite getting hammered by gtown recently at msg, this was the year and this was my hero Mullins last alumni hall game and it was a love fest with the team coming back out from the locker room to thank the fans and all of a sudden Louie was up on Wennington's shoulders! The energy was electric. unfortunately they played.Georgetown another two times.
 
Another magnificent game was sju over Syracuse 82-80 in OT in Jan 85 at msg. Berry hitting the foul line jumper to send it to OT and 19,591 exploding. Pearl doing whatever he wanted and Mullin going for 29 I think. I recall my dad (SJU '68) somehow forgetting lol which lot we parked in and we wandered around the garden for an hour afterwards in 22 degrees or so.
 
One of my favorites was the alumni hall regular season finale vs. I think providence in '85. I was nine at the time and we had season tix up in the old red seats. (Or maybe blue?). After the final buzzer no one wanted to leave because despite getting hammered by gtown recently at msg, this was the year and this was my hero Mullins last alumni hall game and it was a love fest with the team coming back out from the locker room to thank the fans and all of a sudden Louie was up on Wennington's shoulders! The energy was electric. unfortunately they played.Georgetown another two times.

A special senior day game vs PC indeed. The pregame ceremony for the 4 seniors (Mullin, Wennington, Stewart and Moses) was emotional. The whole game was pretty much a tribute for them. After the game ended, they all came back from the locker room with Lou. Wennington did carry coach on his shoulders as you mentioned. Good times.
 
Losses tend to stay longer than wins. The most horoific that I was at was on February 17, 1980 versus Syracuse at Alumni Hall (now CA). Alumni Hall was filled to the rafters with SRO crowd (was the NYFD kept away?). WE were 7th ranked and Cuse was #2. Carter put us up by one with under 30 to go and then we got a Charge on Rencher for a 1 and 1 but he missed the front end. Cuse got off a long pass to Orr and as he crashed into Carter and shot to get and a blocking foul on Reggie. Anyone who was there will go to their grave knowing it should have been a charge on Orr. Louie was irate saying he didn't like the idea of the upstate official making the call!
Remember that one well was sitting right behind our bench. Remember when Rencher when to the free throw line Looie was yelling to him “F em, F em” and after the game we discussing whether or not Rencher interpreted that to mean he should miss the free throw. Also while Carter did get back on D and did draw the charge the rest of the team didn’t allowing Cuse backcourt of Marty Head and Hal Cohen to get the ball up the floor to Orr in the final seconds. Crushing loss as I believe that was first year of BE conference and would have given us outright title instead of tie with Cuse and actually think a three way tie.
 
Many great games already mentioned. Ill add a few (apologies if already mentioned)

SJ win over Russian National Team - vivid memory of Bernard Rencher passing over his back shoulder to a trailing Reggie Carter on a 2 on 1 brerak

SJ win over Tennessee w/3 New Yorkers - Bernie & Ernie (and Irv Chatman)
 
That loss was so depressing that I left the house and walked around Prospect Park lake to try and recover. The win I enjoyed the most was the final of the NIT in 1965 when we beat Villanova for the championship and gave the Big Indian, Joe Lapchick, A fitting send off to end his career. In fact we played three of the best games we ever did displaying the versatility of that team. We ran Roston college off their feet winning 114-92. Next up was New Mexicon ,one of the highest scoring teams in the country, slowing them down winning 61-54. Next beating Army and then Villanova for the title. The Garden was rocking all that week. Glorious times!
It was a long ride home to Miller Place for my Dad and I.
 
A special senior day game vs PC indeed. The pregame ceremony for the 4 seniors (Mullin, Wennington, Stewart and Moses) was emotional. The whole game was pretty much a tribute for them. After the game ended, they all came back from the locker room with Lou. Wennington did carry coach on his shoulders as you mentioned. Good times.
As a long-time ticket holder, I never missed any games. All my business travel was coordinated with the team's schedule. But I had a big Little League rating session that day at Syosset HS for draftable players, and I had to miss that game. One of my regrets. My wife attended with a friend, and I remember her telling me how emotional the recognition of the seniors was. My son's first name is Chris for a reason.
 
espken, could you find the year Catholic U played NYU at MSG? Catholic U won.
and my cousin from long island was the MVP.

Asking because the 2nd game was G-Town vs. SJU, I remember that it was a sea of red, and the 400 level was packed.

Think it almost went into OT but I think a Redmen hit the game winner with like :2 or :3 left, that crowd was loud.
That was my first ever SJU game.

Think is was possibly 87 or 88
 
That loss was so depressing that I left the house and walked around Prospect Park lake to try and recover. The win I enjoyed the most was the final of the NIT in 1965 when we beat Villanova for the championship and gave the Big Indian, Joe Lapchick, A fitting send off to end his career. In fact we played three of the best games we ever did displaying the versatility of that team. We ran Roston college off their feet winning 114-92. Next up was New Mexicon ,one of the highest scoring teams in the country, slowing them down winning 61-54. Next beating Army and then Villanova for the title. The Garden was rocking all that week. Glorious times!
Jackfro--you are lucky the game was not this year or your walk around Prospect Park Lake might have been caaught short by the alligator that was found there this February about a week ago. 🙃 🐊🐊
 
espken, could you find the year Catholic U played NYU at MSG? Catholic U won.
and my cousin from long island was the MVP.

Asking because the 2nd game was G-Town vs. SJU, I remember that it was a sea of red, and the 400 level was packed.

Think it almost went into OT but I think a Redmen hit the game winner with like :2 or :3 left, that crowd was loud.
That was my first ever SJU game.

Think is was possibly 87 or 88
February 2, 1987 @ MSG
Catholic U -84 NYU -74 (1st game of DH)
St.John’s -67 Georgetown-65 OT (2nd game)
Mark Jackson scores 34 points out dueling Reggie Williams.
 
February 2, 1987 @ MSG
Catholic U -84 NYU -74 (1st game of DH)
St.John’s -67 Georgetown-65 OT (2nd game)
Mark Jackson scores 34 points out dueling Reggie Williams.
I think it was 63-63 after regulation. And then it was Jackson 4 Georgetown 2. I recall that being the absolute peak of Mark's incredible run.
 
February 2, 1987 @ MSG
Catholic U -84 NYU -74 (1st game of DH)
St.John’s -67 Georgetown-65 OT (2nd game)
Mark Jackson scores 34 points out dueling Reggie Williams.

February 2, 1987 @ MSG
Catholic U -84 NYU -74 (1st game of DH)
St.John’s -67 Georgetown-65 OT (2nd game)
Mark Jackson scores 34 points out dueling Reggie Williams.
So it did go into OT wow, thanks.

10 yrs old, my mom didn't want me to go because it was on a school night, but we talked her into letting me go.

My cousin said that he didn't play much because he wasn't that good, but started him at MSG, it turned out that, that was his best game in college, somewhere around 24pnts, and he was the mvp.
Then the 2nd game SJU beat G-Town and in OT, I'll never forget that night.

ESPKEN. is the man.
 
Last edited:
I'll go, although my pool of big wins to pull from isn't great lol.


1) Win over #4 Pitt in 2011 at MSG the easiest choice: Still remember watching it with my Dad. We took a timeout before our final possession and my dad said "Hardy is gonna win us this game". Very good call by him. Atmosphere was electric even just watching on TV.

2) We had a win @Xavier during Dom/DLo/Greene's senior year that really got us off the bubble and put us in the drivers seat to make the dance. I remember Marco Baldi a JJ poster was over here during that time and I made a bet with him that if St Johns won, he would have to leave the site forever. If Xavier won, I would have to leave the site forever LOL. So there was some personal stakes for this one too. Even though we ended up calling off the bet before the game, I still just had this good feeling about this one. No one thought we could win at the Cintas Center. We went in there. Sir Dom was electric. We don't talk enough about the jump that dude made in his senior season. He really struggled during his career here, finding his place and his role. Senior year, he had the freedom to just be unleashed. Do everything. Even though I remember that win fondly, I believe DLo tweaked something in his leg that game that never really healed for the rest of the season.



Loss I still can't get over - Coach K's 1,000th win at MSG. We had that freakin game. Had it. We were throwing haymaker after haymaker. But just could not close in the final 5 minutes. Still makes me so mad. Tyus Jones b*tch ass stuck his leg out on a couple three pointers. This was back when refs were consistently falling for that. Flipped the game
 
Favorite wins:

The Holiday Festival win over # 1 Michigan with Cazzie Russell - Johnnie team featured the McIntyre brothers and Sonny Dove (on top of this being a fabulous game and huge upset I believe it was the first or second St. John's game I ever attended);
The upset of Pitt in the Garden when Dwight Hardy made the buzzer beating shot along the baseline;
The MSG blowout of the Duke by Lavin's first team (I was also at this game which always makes it more memorable and loved watching the Duke fans file out early).

Disappointing/haunting losses:
I don't recall the tough losses as vividly as the great wins (probably a much needed coping mechanism for a St. John's fan) but two that stick out:
The MSG overtime loss to #2 Duke where Bootsy had 40 and Artest played great although it was tough to be too disappointed by that great effort;
I also remember the 1967-68 team led by John Warren, Joe Depre & Rudy Bogad losing a one point game at Alumni Hall to Marquette who was led by George Thompson and I believe was a top 10 team at the time. I think this was the second year that my Dad had season's tickets to St. John's games.


Can't find the win at Duke
 
Last edited:
The refs that day were Mickey Crowley, Charles Diehl and Dick Slomkowski.
They screwed us before the infamous non call on Orr. We scored more FG’s than Cuse (30 to 26), but lost the free throw battle (11-18 to 20-30). As well as a technical foul called on the mild mannered Frank Gilroy.
Crowley called the block on Carter. Years later fans would still yell “It was a charge Mickey!!!”
 
Back
Top