update on the Samuel Smith's Organic Chocolate Stout: The emphasis is on the chocolate here. When I first started to drink this I was surprised at how strong the chocolate smell was. The chocolate flavor is too strong and overall flavor is too rich for me. Tastes more like a chocolate soda than beer. Probably similar to what you mentioned @mjmaherjr# with that chocolate / peanut butter porter. Too "desserty" for me. I couldn't even finish it but if someone was a chocolate freak, they'd probably love this.