Cragg had his successes and failures across all the programs. Cragg was responsible for the hiring, extension and firing of Anderson (and took the fall for it). He did some nice things not as visible and worked on getting more alumni support. In the end Cragg was a nice guy and I am sure he tried his best.
As basketball seems to be trending the right way, other sports are not and at least one (Men’s Lacrosse) has never been on the right track. While I know things have changed in terms of popularity and revenue in collegiate baseball with the SEC, ACC and other conferences, our baseball program was a standard bearer for the Northeast but until this year, hadn’t made an appearance in the NCAA Tournament since 2018. While basketball is our bread and butter and “The Program”, the other programs matter also. That all falls under his watch.
St. John’s needs a forward thinking, aggressive, progressive AD who can garner alumni support, be a successful fundraiser, be able to navigate the changing structure of college athletics, understand and make use of all available media and technology, have ideas better enhance facilities and a strategy to implement them, provide support for all programs and make use of our strengths. IMHO, there is no one in house who is the right fit.
I am hopping they actually do a legitimate national search and can think of two locals who do have several of those qualities and experience albeit on a smaller scale who should at least be considered. Like the last basketball head coach search, at this time of the ever changing landscape of college athletics, it is imperative they get this right because if they don’t ….