[quote="panther2" post=287461][quote="Beast of the East" post=287460][quote="Chicago Days" post=287457][quote="Class of 72" post=287453][quote="AlBovino" post=287450]Great job Fordham96 comparing RJ Barrett the best freshman in the country to David Caraher. Comparing Barrett to Mustapha Heron would be much more equitable. So who would you rather have Barrett for one year or Heron for two years?[/quote]
I agree when you say "Comparing Barrett to Mustapha Heron would be much more equitable."
Hopefully this season we will get to do just that because RJ is a lottery pick.
Every time I see his name associated with Duke I want to punch a wall!
The son of an alum never gave St. John's a NY minute of consideration.
I can't wait for the Heron-Barrett matchup!!![/quote]
Yes ‘72 very depressing that “the son of an alum...” didn’t give us as much as a NY minute.
Hopefully, the tide she be turning.[/quote]
With 6 coaches in 25 years, several ADs, and investing much less than other schools in athletic department infrastructure, you wonder if the school has much of an outreach to former athletes. You also need coaches that can get beyond the continual cycle of large scale roster rebuild that the last 3 coaches encountered. You also need coaches with a sense of history that understand how important it is to keep former players and coaches close to the program. I wouldn't put this all on Barrett, or on any former player whose kid becomes a high profile recruit.[/quote]
RJ Barrett is the best player in this class, I can't blame his father for choosing Duke. As Beast stated, we have not yet shown that we are a stable program. Choosing a college for these kids is like investing money for posters on this board, you go to the one with the best guarantee of maximizing your investment. Hopefully, this is the year that we begin to win and change the perception of our program.
I am a proud alum of St. Johns. However, if my granddaughter is offered scholarships to St. Johns and Harvard when she graduates from high school, she is going to Harvard.[/quote]
Great post, for an RJ Barrett to pick a college is strictly a business decision, nothing more, nothing less. The overwhelming majority of players with his ability (and there aren't all that many) would not play a minute in college if not forced to. He played for three high schools, winding up at one hundreds, if not thousands of miles from his home. The idea that he would have some type of allegiance to SJU because his father played here is ludicrous to me. It is an absolutely different world and the astronomical transfer numbers we see in college are just reflective of the world these players grow up in, jumping between AAU teams and high schools at a moments notice. Just the way it is. Maybe some day SJU will be a realistic destination for this level player but I sure as hell would not be holding my breath waiting for that day.