Breaking it down:
1) The players: I don't hate either team's players. No more than I'd hate North Koreans, Cubans, Persians. Victims of their regimes.
2) The coaches: I don't like the Rat. I don't like Boeheim - but found I dislike Boeheim less as years go by. He'd have stayed in the BE, always spoke well of our program in serious moments. The Rat is just the Rat - says the right things outwardly. Slight edge to Cuse here because I've found I'm disliking Boeheim less over time. The sideline tantrums, the most annoying coach on the bench, the whining to refs have diminished considerably over time
3) The fans - Syracuse fans are more annoying during games. In our house, MSG, they take it over. Duke fans, at least the ones that travel here, are merely brighter, more successful, and probably wealthier than Cuse fans, are more subdued in MSG. Off the court, I like the Cuse alums I know. Toss up.
4) The circumstances - Duke, core part of the carpet bagging ACC who took Syracuse for what? - money. Syracuse, grabbed at the money - when is enough is enough? Answer - never.
5) Location: If you're from my family, I'd side with you against anyone in my neighborhood. If you're from my neighborhood, I'd side with you against an outsider. Syracuse is still NY, so my gut says go with them.
Hmm. I don't see any reasons to want either Duke or Syracuse, but I guess it would bring me a slight satisfaction knowing a BE team is ripping the ACC to shreds.
Ok I'm for Syracuse, and Syracuse will win.