Sha did an excellent job with Seton Hall this year. Yes, the talent is better than folks thought preseason for sure when you consider how well Richmond, Davis and Dawes played for most of the season, plus Bediako being better on the glass/interior than anyone would have foreseen. And he didn't develop his bench, either because he doesn't have much or because he chose to ride his starters thinking that gave him the best chance of winning as many conference games as possible, which they needed. Remember the Hall's OOC was putrid. He didn't schedule that strong, and they lost to every high major they played (all of whom except Baylor aren't tourney or even close to tourney teams), and their biggest W was against a historically awful Missouri team. The only reason a Big East team with 13 conference W's, including Ws over Uconn and Marquette, is on the bubble is because of how bad the OOC was for the Hall.
All that said, Hurley still gets my vote for Coach of the Year. They were picked 3rd in the league, and are heads and shoulders better than everyone IMO, including the second and third best teams. Lose 3 players to the league, get picked 3rd, and run through the league like a knife through warm butter, you get my vote.