America's 35 Best Pizzas

 Colosseo's in Port Jefferson would easily be on that list if they knew about it.
 Same with Lee's on SI. Thanks for the link. I would like to try the other spots around the area.
 
Nominate Little Vincent's (Ronkonkoma-Suffolk Co. L.I.) and Umberto's. 
 
Ok the list is not all bad as Difara's is really that good. You must eat it there hot out of the oven but it is bar none the best I have ever had. As for the rest of the list how does anthony's make it and Grimaldi's get left off. And any pizza in cali? Have oyu ever had pizza in Cali? Really stick to sushi and chineese food there unless you have a pinapple or goat cheese fetish.

I do love Umburtos as it was a staple growing up but I dont think it belongs in the lofty realms of top 10.

If anyone is traveeling on sunrise highway around west babylon, north babylon area try Cafe Gio. They have regular pie with a garlic knote crust that is amazing and a stuffed meat pizza that you will have trouble finishing a slice.
 
Nominate Little Vincent's (Ronkonkoma-Suffolk Co. L.I.) and Umberto's. 
 

gotta be related to the little vin cents in huntington. Oh man I love that pizza

Grimaldis personal pies in garden city with extra cheese,meatballs and onions is literally the prefect pizza
 
Nominate Little Vincent's (Ronkonkoma-Suffolk Co. L.I.) and Umberto's. 
 

gotta be related to the little vin cents in huntington. Oh man I love that pizza

Grimaldis personal pies in garden city with extra cheese,meatballs and onions is literally the prefect pizza
 

Umbertos in NHP makes a great pizza, and on Fridays during lent I never saw cash flying into a cash register so fast as there.

New Park Pizza in Howard Beach has great pizza too - people come back to Howard beach from miles around on a pilgrimmage here.

There was a great place on Liberty Avenue near Cross Bay blvd that used fresh Mozzarella (not pizza cheese) and plenty of fresh tomato sauce on a very crisp pie - I forget the name of the place tho - it was more of a restaurant and a few doors down from the Cross Bay Theatre
 
Nominate Little Vincent's (Ronkonkoma-Suffolk Co. L.I.) and Umberto's. 
 

gotta be related to the little vin cents in huntington. Oh man I love that pizza

Grimaldis personal pies in garden city with extra cheese,meatballs and onions is literally the prefect pizza
 

Grims GC is definitely better than Grims Brooklyn Heights! Brooklyn has that mean old bastard harassing the customers while in GC they welcome you with open arms.
BTW, you will never see a pizza with meatballs on it in Italy! LOL!
 
Nominate Little Vincent's (Ronkonkoma-Suffolk Co. L.I.) and Umberto's. 
 

gotta be related to the little vin cents in huntington. Oh man I love that pizza

Grimaldis personal pies in garden city with extra cheese,meatballs and onions is literally the prefect pizza
 

Grims GC is definitely better than Grims Brooklyn Heights! Brooklyn has that mean old bastard harassing the customers while in GC they welcome you with open arms.
BTW, you will never see a pizza with meatballs on it in Italy! LOL!
 

you know what ? when my girlfriend and I were in Italy a couple of years ago I didn't love the pizza. Had a slice in Venice at a touristy place that was real good but other than that nothing memorable. Now the wine and pasta a completely different story but the pizza itself didn't wow us
 
Nominate Little Vincent's (Ronkonkoma-Suffolk Co. L.I.) and Umberto's. 
 

gotta be related to the little vin cents in huntington. Oh man I love that pizza

Grimaldis personal pies in garden city with extra cheese,meatballs and onions is literally the prefect pizza
 

Grims GC is definitely better than Grims Brooklyn Heights! Brooklyn has that mean old bastard harassing the customers while in GC they welcome you with open arms.
BTW, you will never see a pizza with meatballs on it in Italy! LOL!
 

you know what ? when my girlfriend and I were in Italy a couple of years ago I didn't love the pizza. Had a slice in Venice at a touristy place that was real good but other than that nothing memorable. Now the wine and pasta a completely different story but the pizza itself didn't wow us
 

The baked ziti slice at Di Raimos in huntington is real good.

If anyone knows of a great slice of Sicilian let me know. The best I ever had was at " Delicious Pizza " in Glen Cove when I was a kid them they sold it and the new owner f'd it up and when one of the sons opened up a new one like 10 years later it was never the same
 
Nominate Little Vincent's (Ronkonkoma-Suffolk Co. L.I.) and Umberto's. 
 

gotta be related to the little vin cents in huntington. Oh man I love that pizza

Grimaldis personal pies in garden city with extra cheese,meatballs and onions is literally the prefect pizza
 

Grims GC is definitely better than Grims Brooklyn Heights! Brooklyn has that mean old bastard harassing the customers while in GC they welcome you with open arms.
BTW, you will never see a pizza with meatballs on it in Italy! LOL!
 

you know what ? when my girlfriend and I were in Italy a couple of years ago I didn't love the pizza. Had a slice in Venice at a touristy place that was real good but other than that nothing memorable. Now the wine and pasta a completely different story but the pizza itself didn't wow us
 

The baked ziti slice at Di Raimos in huntington is real good.

If anyone knows of a great slice of Sicilian let me know. The best I ever had was at " Delicious Pizza " in Glen Cove when I was a kid them they sold it and the new owner f'd it up and when one of the sons opened up a new one like 10 years later it was never the same
 


VI Pizza in Bayside has the best sicilian slices!
 
Nominate Little Vincent's (Ronkonkoma-Suffolk Co. L.I.) and Umberto's. 
 

gotta be related to the little vin cents in huntington. Oh man I love that pizza

Grimaldis personal pies in garden city with extra cheese,meatballs and onions is literally the prefect pizza
 

Grims GC is definitely better than Grims Brooklyn Heights! Brooklyn has that mean old bastard harassing the customers while in GC they welcome you with open arms.
BTW, you will never see a pizza with meatballs on it in Italy! LOL!
 

you know what ? when my girlfriend and I were in Italy a couple of years ago I didn't love the pizza. Had a slice in Venice at a touristy place that was real good but other than that nothing memorable. Now the wine and pasta a completely different story but the pizza itself didn't wow us
 

There are two reasons you did not have memorable pizza-----(1) You had it in Venice; (2) You had a "slice" which is considered focaccia in Italy.
The only true and authentic pizza in Italy has to be Pizza Napolentane and be DOC.

Here are the guidelines for all pizzas to be considered authentic:

DOC pizza is governed by a Neopolitan member of The Association of Pizzaioli Europei called the Association of Vera Pizza Napoletana or "The Association of True Neopolitan Pizza". Their ten rules for pizza are as follows:

1) Pizza dough must be made with flour, water, yeast and salt only. No additives such as oil, fat, sugar or milk are allowed.

2) Pizza must be no greater than 30 cm. (12 inches)

3) Dough should not be heated by the mixing process. (slow electrical mixers or hand mixing only)

4) Dough must be hand stretched, no rollers or presses.

5) The oven must be made of refractory material such as brick or castable refractory and fired with wood.

6) The pizza must be cooked on the floor of the oven. (no pans)

7) Pizza must be cooked at 400 deg. C. or higher. (750 deg. F)

8) Pizza should be well done, fragrant, with the cornicione (border) high and soft. Pizza should not be crusty.

9) Four styles are well defined:
Marinara: tomato, oregano, olive oil, salt
Margherita: tomato, mozzarella, olive oil, garlic, basil, salt
Al Formaggio: parmesean, lard, garlic, basil, salt
Calzone: ricotta, salami, olive oil, salt

10) Variations on the four styles are allowed as long as they are in good taste and do not violate other culinary rules or regulations.
 
 I guess I'm just a pizza ho. I've never met a piece of pizza I didn't like! :lol:
 
 I guess I'm just a pizza ho. I've never met a piece of pizza I didn't like! :lol:
 

LOL! You sound like Woody Allen who said:
“Pizza is a lot like sex. When it's good, it's really good. When it's bad, it's still pretty good.”
 
The link is not loading right on my computer, but if L&B Spumoni Gardens in Brooklyn isn't near the top of that list, the list is garbage. Best square/sicilian slice I've ever had.
In terms of Long Island, I was always a fan of Carmela's on the border of Massapequa and Seaford on Merrick Rd.

I'm not going to lie, being a New Yorker, but I had the deep dish at Lou Malnati's in the heart of Chicago and it was one of the best things I've ever had in my life. When the wife was pregnant, I surprised her by ordering 4 pies via Tastes of Chicago and even though they weren't like the restaurant, they were definitely sufficient. They cam shipped in dry ice and they broke down to 20 bucks a pie.
 
 I guess I'm just a pizza ho. I've never met a piece of pizza I didn't like! :lol:
 

Get pizza in 98 percent of the "pizzerias" outside of the tri-state area and you might be singing a different tune. Actually, if you're boozed up you probably won't care. I would take DiGiornio's frozen pizza over a slice outside of the Tri-state.
 
 I guess I'm just a pizza ho. I've never met a piece of pizza I didn't like! :lol:
 

Get pizza in 98 percent of the "pizzerias" outside of the tri-state area and you might be singing a different tune. Actually, if you're boozed up you probably won't care. I would take DiGiornio's frozen pizza over a slice outside of the Tri-state.
 I just came back from LA and I was forced fed a slice of pizza. Was shockingly good. Still doesn't compare to around here but would eat it again.
 
Back
Top