Class of 72
Active member
The truth of the matter is that very bright high school students ..... do not want to attend a college made up of close to 40% minority students with whom they have very little in common except hip-hop music.
Class of '72:
Your suggestion that race is a defense to St. John's mediocre undergrad academic recognition is not correct.
Below is a list of only some of the colleges that have substantial undergrad minority enrollments and which rank ahead of St.John's in the US News rankings including the below listed schools. (Note the percentage indicated the percent of students in the frosh 2010 class that were classified as "white".).
U Illinois- Chicago... 37%
South Carolina State University... 1%
U Texas- Dallas... 43%
Rutgers- Newark... 29%
New York Poly ... 32%
New Jersey Tech... 25%
Stony Brook ... 37%
University of the Pacific ... 38%
UC Riverside ... 13%
Binghamton ... 51%
UC Santa Cruz ... 39%
rutgers ... 46%
UC Irvine ... 20%
UC Santa Barbara ... 44%
UMiami ... 52%
San Diego ... 23%
New York University ... 44%
UCLA ... 25%
USC ... 41%
Cal ... 28%
Emory ... 38%
Rice ... 40%
UPenn ... 49%
UChicago ... 49%
Stanford ... 32%
Cal Tech ... 33%
Princeton ... 50%
Yale ... 49%
Harvard ... 44%
Cornell ... 46%
Brown ... 44%
Columbia University ... 33%
There is no way to spin the facts that (i) St. John's has a disturbing high attrition rate (nearly one of four students that enroll as a frosh quits or transfers- 22%), (ii) those that do graduate incur a heavy debt load (average debt $32,886), and (iii) the school that has a mediocre academic reputation (#152 National University).
The school's alums should demand that Rev. Donald J. Harrington, C.M. remedy these deficiencies much like they demanded that he right the men's basketball program.
OTIS, I respect you as a Redmen fan HOWEVER I am starting to think you are actually a SJ hater.
Presenting misleading stats does not serve you well in this discussion. I almost took your retort seriously until I saw South Carolina State on your list as a school you say are ranked higher than SJ yet 99% of the students are African American! LMAO!!
Let's get some of your stats straigt here! You have a bunch of Ivies on your list as having a high % of minorities as well as Cal Berkley and some other "engineering" schools. Yet, you fail to mention that the so-called minorities in the schools you list are ASIAN!! Now I think you know you can fool some of the Redmen fans here but some of us actually were involved with education and know better! When I made reference to certain high achieving white students that exclude SJ it was not because too many ASIANS were attending SJ!! Not ONE school on your list has a higher % of African-American and Hispanic (non-Mexican) population than SJ----NONE!
As far as the US News rankings I personally think they have compromised their credibility with the 2012 rankings and rendered any school ranked after the top 50 as almost equals. Nonsense!!! I am very familiar with NYU-PolyTech as a close friend was a dean there. Do you really think that Rensselear in Troy NY is really 60 places higher in ranking when it comes to producing engineers??? Another friend taught at Miami in Coral Gables. the school is full of rich white and Cuban White kids riding BMW's to school! At one time, before the bullshit US. News rankings, St. Johns's was actually considered a better school.
To reiterate, St. John's can easily emulate Fordham and Villanova. All it has to do is not accept low-income black and Hispanic students with lower SATs. Fifty years ago some of you were white Irish or Italian kids from low-income immigrant families but SJ gave you an opportunity Some dropped out but some, like former Gov Mario Cuomo whose parents had a little grocery store, became very influential grads.
BTW OTIS, you failed to mention that THREE Big East FOOTBALL schools (your favorite topic) are all ranked BELOW SJ! Way to Go Louisville, West Virginia and USF!!!