Here's the uncomfortable truth about the play in games, if you lose in those, it never even feels like you were in the tournament.Play-in games got us a ticket to the dance before.
Another way to look at play-in games is that it begins the Tourny and 60 teams get byes.
You don't get to be a part of the best two sports days of the year IMO (first round - Thurs and Fri)
You also don't even get to pick your own team when you fill out your bracket. For example, if we are in the play in game this year against say Wake Forest, on the bracket you fill out, it just says WF/SJU. You don't even get your own spot in the bracket which means no one is going to pick you to go far, if they don't even know who they're picking! Not until Tuesday/Wednesday night will it be changed, and the overwhelming majority of people have already filled out their bracket by then. This may sound like a small complaint but it is undoubtedly true, going to Dayton is LAME