I'm surprised to see so much discussion of "one more year..."
For a couple of small guards, a couple years on campus to train and add muscle seems like a good idea. And with a good competitive season next year followed by a significant tournament run the following year, the chances of a legitimate NBA pay check might be more realistic.
Or course, that scenario has more to do with my own selfish interests...
I'm surprised also- I doubt Lovett would sit out a full year, just to play one year, and he is not going to sit out another year to transfer, and Ponds isn't going anywhere.
Agree with you both and think most would be surprised for all of the legitimate reasons mentioned and others. But surprise in a lot ways has become a regular occurrence on this topic.
In addition to that general point it's been alluded to enough by reliable posters, and there have been enough interesting developments, to think it's at least a reasonable possibility.
Difficult to disparage any player's decision to make money playing professionally. You just hope that decision is smart and considerate of long-term earnings, not just what is available at that moment.
With that in mind key question here, from my outside perspective and with no knowledge of any individual circumstances: "is the NBA realistic?"
If it is, staying in college for at least one more year is likely prudent. It's easier to generate NBA prospect momentum this way, playing for winning team, earning individual accolades, getting media coverage, at a level where scouts have no questions about the competition, etc. An international league as an interim step to further develop towards the NBA while also making money seems to be a less probable proposition if you're a borderline case.
If it isn't, then makes even more sense why someone might want to just start getting paid earlier.
With what they've shown the last month in particular, performing in their first year in the Big East in an exceptionally "complete" manner with very little adjustment period, my view is the NBA is realistic for both of our guards. Perhaps not this year, but in the next few. Lovett has NBA speed and Ponds has NBA skills. They are small and need to get stronger but you look at the last few drafts and what's projected this year, especially in the 2nd round obviously, and there are comparables.
So my hope, not just for SJU but hopefully also for them, is that they are here at least one more year to have a go at generating that kind of pro prospect momentum. But again I don't know anything about any individual situations or any other circumstances. Obviously, both staying would be a massive thing for the program as it gives a very enhanced chance at making the tournament next year and perhaps even more importantly helps bridge to what will hopefully be very strong 2018 recruiting.