If you were unhappy with the crowd last night, your expectations are too high. First of all CA is not a nice arena at all. Second of all it was against DePaul. Besides those facts, the place still looked 90% packed. Of course no one sits all the way at the top, because you are literally staring at beams in the ceiling. The crowd was great.
Hard for you to believe, but for years on end we nearly sold the entire arena out on season tickets. I recall sitting in my seats in a sold out alumni hall before we even had a student section wondering if they were losing future fans since students couldn't get into the place without buying a season ticket.
All the way at the top in a place that seats less than 6,000? You really have to be kidding. Try watching a game from the cheap seats in the Carrier Dome when there are 30,000 in attendance and see how tiny the players from the upper reaches. You can make all the excuses you want, but when your school plays in one of the top three conferences in the US, has a winning streak, and a winning record, and you can't draw 5,000 for an in conference opponent, something is wrong.
There are far worse places to play than CA. I just read a very fine book by Kriegel on Pistol Pete Maravich. The gym at LSU was a horrible dump, but given a reason to come out (Maravich) even very deep in football country at a school that never drew for basketball, people mobbed the place. He was so heralded asa freshman, the freshman game would be packed and people would leave before the varsity game.
The problem with most dumb fans is, well, they are dumb. As soon as we break the top twenty five or top 15, beat some ranked opponents, then all of a sudden fans will flock to the games. Most fans can only tell great basketball by the team's record, and will ignore the ascent from fair to mediocre to good to great. They will only show up for a great, and then proclaim their forever undying allegiance.
Students will find the money for travel, expensive food and drink, and tickets. Workers in NYC will suddenly plan their day around a St John's game again, stay in the city after work to fill the Garden. All of this nonsensical talk about bleachers, crappy arenas, cost of travel, etc. will all go away. Right now, even if we had a Staples Center on campus, we wouldn't draw many more fans for SJU-DePAul than we did last night.