Beast of the East wrote:
Simple answer is that it's easy to look at his boxscore over the past few games and be an armchair quarterback, but the conventional thinking looking at the way he's moved is that Harrison on one leg is better than Branch on two. We are, after all, talking about a guy who was nominated for the Wooden award and was playing at that level prior to the injury
The simple answer you refer to makes no sense. Even if the Coach believes Harrison is better on one leg than Branch is on two, no one could argue Harrison is better on one leg than Harrison is on two. The one legged Harrison does not warrant playing 38 minutes a game and you don't need a box score to know that. That comes from watching the games.
In addition to that it does not explain why Branch's minutes have been cut nearly in half during this stretch of games. The Marquette game was turned around during the four minute stretch in the final ten minutes of the second half when Harrison sat and Branch played. During that time St. John's went on a 10 to 3 run that turned a likely loss into a victory.
Harrison is a very deserving Wooden award nominee and has a huge heart, but if you have watched the last three games he has not been anywhere close to that player. Additionally Branch in the forty minutes, he did play, has been steady with seven assists and only one turnover while playing solid defense.
I hope D'Angelo returns to 100 % ASAP. We are in serious trouble if he does not get better soon. That being said, I also hope that some common sense approach is applied by our Coaches about how the minutes are allocated when any player (even our star) is well below his best.
Like I said, your entire argument is looking backwards, and the results justify your argument. But when you have a guy who was putting up a string of 20-30 point games, isn't limping, and is your best player, you put him out there. I agree that the injury could be affecting his jumper, but he hasn't exactly been a big liability on defense. The team simply did not appear poised to replace those 20-30 points per game with Branch, who contributes little. As I mentioned in prior posts, the pleasant surprise is how much of that load Jordan has taken on, and looks entirely comfortable right now.