[quote="MCNPA" post=376606][quote="dee" post=376603][quote="SJU61982" post=376553][quote="MCNPA" post=376550][quote="SJU61982" post=376547][quote="Las Vegan" post=376535]Right now, we are in a poor bargaining position with MSG. It's either there or on campus. When the new arena, at Belmont, is available, SJU has a very viable alternative to MSG.
[/quote]
I've said this before, but I really wouldn't mind making the Belmont arena our new full time home, when it opens. It's right on the Queens/LI border, so that satisfies probably 90% of the fanbase.
Maybe we could do something like Seton Hall does (though less so this year, obviously) at the Rock, where they close off the upper bowl. I always felt that was effective in bringing more of a homecourt advantage, to a pro style arena, and that's something we could use, because MSG is either empty, or 60% opposing fans, so we gain no advantage. It's why I don't like bringing recruits to games there. I always fear that they'll wind up loving the other team more, when they see that spirited crowd.
I also think we could get a more favorable schedule, playing there. We'd be second only to the Islanders WRT dates and times. At MSG, we're fourth at most, behind the Knicks, Rangers, and Billy Joel, and then there's all those other events the Garden has, like the Dog Show, the Rodeo, The Big 10 Challenge, Z100s Jingle Ball, etc. That's why we play so many noon weekend games there. There really aren't any other spots where they can take us. At Belmont, IMO, we'll get a fairer shake.[/quote]
It isn’t going to be a substitute for MSG. We need MSG. It’s our home away from campus. That said, having a great new arena at Belmont is a fantastic new option that really opens up more for us because it is soooo close to campus. Maybe SJU wants to start a D1 ice hockey team? ;-)[/quote]
It's not going to replace MSG, I know that, but maybe it should. If you want to maximize your win total, while keeping recruiting strong, it might be the way to go.
CA is worthless, we know that. Great atmosphere when rocking, but not a recruiting tool.
MSG is also not all it's cracked up to be, for us. What advantage do we have for that? All the other Big East schools can at least guarantee to a kid, that he'll play there in the Big East Tournament? Obviously, a few extra games per year does not make a big difference to these kids. Also, what are you going to sell the building on? The Knicks? There's a nice laugh. High School kids today only know the Knicks as losers.
Belmont arena will be state of the art (hopefully), with a smaller, more intimate atmosphere (if we take a page from Seton Hall's book), and with a more favorable schedule of dates. Hopefully, we can turn it into our version of the Dunkin Donuts Center, in Providence. That's what I'm looking for.[/quote]
You guys are nuts with a capital N. We need msg. Every kid wants to play there. It is one of the few if only draw we have left.[/quote]
Gulp.... I agree with Dee. It’s a huge recruiting tool for us. It will always be very important for our upward potential. Now fielding a good team is what we need to do.[/quote]
It's not that great of a recruiting tool, since we haven't brought big time recruits in for quite awhile, now. Unfortunately, the best recruiting tools aren't legal, and it's not scaring off teams from using them.
But even beyond that, as I said before, any other Big East team can still use MSG WRT recruits, because they can guarantee the kids that they will play there in the Big East Tournament. Not to mention, that some of those kids might be more attracted to the atmosphere created there by the fans of the opposing school, so bringing them to games there might not always be in our best interests, either.