Almost impossible as SJU fans not to have our perspective distorted by our position. There is a concept that essentially says that observing an event just a few feet from another objective observer changes your perception of reality.
To me, in college basketball, coaches stand above players due to longevity and success in being architects of program building. The best players typically play 1 to 3 years today, and it's hard to compare that to 15, 20, or 30 years coaching a program.
That being said, arguably, when you think of the most successful Big East schools, when you think of UCONN's success Calhoun is the first name that comes to mind, Georgetown Thompson. Syracuse Boeheim, and Villanova Wright.
Those are the 4 most successful BE programs and their coaches rank with the very best all time, both college and pro.
Looie's value to our university is unparalleled and would put him above all others in that regard. He embodies Vincentian values and espouses them at every opportunity in word and deed. As a coach he may actually be second to Lapchick. Looie's 70 plus year association with the school is just mind boggling however.
Gavitt as a founder and commissioner is notable but just doesn't warrant what the above 5 mean to the BE.
Beast you are right from an impact standpoint but as a fan while I appreciate what the coaches do it is the players that I enjoyed the most especially from my younger days. Mullin, Ewing and Pearl and Iverson stand out but there were so many great ones mentioned here. Looie of course stands out as he was ours.