No, she's a lot prettier than Mark but she griped about helmet head and had to get her hair done on the boat. They did a good job though and we used the scooter every day. The island is 23 miles long and we covered it all. I keeep going back because it's the best place I know. If anyone has any other recommendations I'd like to hear them.
Obviously I'll have to wait to compare the two, but St. John in the USVI is pretty stunning. About 60 percent of the island is a national park so naturally it's cleaner, less populated, less developed, harder to get to (about 90 mins from the St. Thomas airport including a ferry) and home to some of the the Caribbean's best beaches.
If you're really adventurous, I would suggest the Cook Islands in the South Pacific - perhaps my favorite place in the world. Air New Zealand flies directly from L.A. to Rarotonga. It's nine hours, but worth it. Polynesian hospitality, bungalows a few steps from the beach, mountains covered by a rainforest, a never-ending breeze, super clean and a coral reef that surrounds the island making for calm, bathtub-like waters. I can think of no better place to decompress and forget about the rest of the world.