2025-26 NY Football Giants

classof2010 said:
All around bad game. Schoen along with Daboll need to be fired after the season.
Click to expand...
Put everyone out of their misery and fire both after the Thursday night game. Hard to fire someone on a short week.

After Philly demolishes them, the changes can commence. Have Kafka interim head coach and Brandon Brown interim GM for the rest of the season. This is not to say they have earned it. This is just to get a head start on the process.
 
What is really disappointing is they had a chance to get some momentum if they beat the 0-4 Saints, and early in the game I thought they were going to do just that, going up 14-3.

After that they just crapped the bed, I'm not watching Thursday nights garbage, Philly will eat them for lunch.

NY sports is just bad right now, Yankees had to be the worst 26 games over 500 in the history of baseball.
That is just mind blowing, they have looked so bad this year at times and for good stretches, hth were they 26 games over 500?
 
SJUWillRockNYC said:
What is really disappointing is they had a chance to get some momentum if they beat the 0-4 Saints, and early in the game I thought they were going to do just that, going up 14-3.

After that they just crapped the bed, I'm not watching Thursday nights garbage, Philly will eat them for lunch.

NY sports is just bad right now, Yankees had to be the worst 26 games over 500 in the history of baseball.
That is just mind blowing, they have looked so bad this year at times and for good stretches, hth were they 26 games over 500?
Click to expand...
NYC is a “Professional” Basketball town w Knicks & Johnnies. 😎
 
Gotta hope Giants lose out then get a new gm, that new guy would want his QB.

So lets take a look at the top 5:
Mendoza, Sellers, Moore, Mateer, and Garrett.

I haven't been looking at college QBs as I still like Dart, but as I said the new GM would want his QB. Probably would let that guy and Dart battle it out next year.
After that I'd strictly focus on drafting an o-line.
 
They need to use their first 5 picks on the O-Line. You could have Joe Montana back there and it wouldn't matter
 
kranmars said:
Put everyone out of their misery and fire both after the Thursday night game. Hard to fire someone on a short week.

After Philly demolishes them, the changes can commence. Have Kafka interim head coach and Brandon Brown interim GM for the rest of the season. This is not to say they have earned it. This is just to get a head start on the process.
Click to expand...
If we could trade our pick for Sean McVays services end of the season I’d be happy!
 
SJUWillRockNYC said:
Gotta hope Giants lose out then get a new gm, that new guy would want his QB.

So lets take a look at the top 5:
Mendoza, Sellers, Moore, Mateer, and Garrett.

I haven't been looking at college QBs as I still like Dart, but as I said the new GM would want his QB. Probably would let that guy and Dart battle it out next year.
After that I'd strictly focus on drafting an o-line.
Click to expand...

I'm telling Jaxson that you want to give up on him already :) He was your boy all last year.

They will not take another QB this year. The roster still has 50 holes on it. There is no sure thing QB in the class.

It's been how many years and the OL is still and mess and any WR not named Nabers can't create separation. The Giants are slow. Watch other NFL games and guys flying around. Watch Giants and its like they are in quicksand.
 
SJUWillRockNYC said:
Wouldn't mind proctor from Alabama, he's a Larry Allen type, 6-7 366. Big and wide.

Or the kid from Miami.
Click to expand...
Call it short sighted but after Evan Neal I'm not touching another Bama OT. Plus their OL always seem to bust.

The two tackles from Utah are studs. Fano > Lomu. Isaiah World from Oregon is real good. Mauigoa some think doesn't have the good ole length to be a OT at next level. But would be stud guard.
 
SJUWillRockNYC said:
Gotta hope Giants lose out then get a new gm, that new guy would want his QB.

So lets take a look at the top 5:
Mendoza, Sellers, Moore, Mateer, and Garrett.

I haven't been looking at college QBs as I still like Dart, but as I said the new GM would want his QB. Probably would let that guy and Dart battle it out next year.
After that I'd strictly focus on drafting an o-line.
Click to expand...
I think it would be wrong to give up on Dart after less than one year worth of game experience.

Let’s remember Eli struggled mightily his first year, with skill position players better than the embarrassing cast the Giants line up. That is Shoen’s biggest dereliction of duty. Look around the league and you will see every team with multiple functional WRs.

Not the Giants. With Nabers, the Giants had miserable WRs. After Nabers injury, the position is by far the worst in the league. No one is close. Just look at how Collins gave up on his route resulting in Dart’s first interception.

Then add in that the college QBs you listed have hardly been world beaters.

I think Dart has moxie. Will it translate into a franchise QB, who knows? But he is a willing study.
 
Moose said:
I'm telling Jaxson that you want to give up on him already :) He was your boy all last year.

They will not take another QB this year. The roster still has 50 holes on it. There is no sure thing QB in the class.

It's been how many years and the OL is still and mess and any WR not named Nabers can't create separation. The Giants are slow. Watch other NFL games and guys flying around. Watch Giants and its like they are in quicksand.
Click to expand...
Lol not giving up on Dart but if there is a new GM, they want their own.

I'd rather get some big wide hogs up front.
 
kranmars said:
I think it would be wrong to give up on Dart after less than one year worth of game experience.

Let’s remember Eli struggled mightily his first year, with skill position players better than the embarrassing cast the Giants line up. That is Shoen’s biggest dereliction of duty. Look around the league and you will see every team with multiple functional WRs.

Not the Giants. With Nabers, the Giants had miserable WRs. After Nabers injury, the position is by far the worst in the league. No one is close. Just look at how Collins gave up on his route resulting in Dart’s first interception.

Then add in that the college QBs you listed have hardly been world beaters.

I think Dart has moxie. Will it translate into a franchise QB, who knows? But he is a willing study.
Click to expand...
Shoen needs to go, but the next GM has to be the right guy. This firing and hiring every 4-5 years sucks.

They someone with a clue.
 
SJUWillRockNYC said:
Lol not giving up on Dart but if there is a new GM, they want their own.

I'd rather get some big wide hogs up front.
Click to expand...
A GM might want their own but they have a cost controlled QB for 4 more years who they sacrificed picks for. If the QB class was shaping up different maybe but I'd bet a lot the Giants don't take a QB the first 2 days next year. They don't have a 3rd round pick remember.

Best case scenario is team tanks, Schoen and Daboll are fired. And someone wants to trade up with Giants and we can stash a few more picks because lord knows we need more lotto tickets.
 
SJUWillRockNYC said:
Gotta hope Giants lose out then get a new gm, that new guy would want his QB.

So lets take a look at the top 5:
Mendoza, Sellers, Moore, Mateer, and Garrett.

I haven't been looking at college QBs as I still like Dart, but as I said the new GM would want his QB. Probably would let that guy and Dart battle it out next year.
After that I'd strictly focus on drafting an o-line.
Click to expand...
Look at what Daniel Jones is doing this year

You give up quicker than the French 😀
 
Moose said:
QB room is set for next year. Dart and Winston on the cheap.

Trade Russell for ANY draft pick. Rather take the lotto ticket.
Click to expand...
Can't believe Bengals traded for Flacco. Behind that OL he's going to struggle. At least trade for a guy who can move.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top