I have waited a day to post this. I have watched almost every game (or listened to some games in the 70's ) now for 57 years. The Marquette game was the single most exciting game I have ever witnessed in all that time.
I have great memories starting with Louie Rothel's hook shot, in the air with no time on the clock, to beat UTah in the Garden in '57 or so, to Lapchicks last win in the NIT with the McIntires and Houston in '65; the 1959 NIT championship with Seiden and Gus Alfieri; the BE win in '86 with Rowan's shot from the corner and ten STJ hands on the shot by Pearl at the buzzer; the Jarvis team win in early 90's in the Garden against Kentucky, the first and only game in the nation that season and all the lights in the nation were ON, the slapping of Chicago Loyola when they were #1 at Carnesecca, the back to back to back by Louie over Texas, Indiana, and Maryland, the win over #1 Georgetown and Michigan and a handful of others.
The game this week against the Golden Eagles was, by a huge margin, the most exciting game I have ever seen STJ play from start to finish. Most of my other highlights were won by last second heroics with 38 minutes of mostly forgettable basketball before those last seconds. This game was monumental in every respect.
Prior to this, the best game I ever saw was between Syracuse and Maryland for the Eastern Regionals, the year when the the Terrapins won the whole thing. This game wasn't as artistic but it was more exciting from the tip to the last buzzer. Ten ties, 14 lead changes, identical team stats for the most part, and both team kids giving their hearts, their bodies, their guts for 50 minutes.
I have never seen a more exciting game! I am really emotional that we won. If there ever was a game when "the last team who had the ball would win" this was it even though we won with them holding the ball at the end. ( a Tribute to remarkable and courageous coaching that I would not have had).
In 57 years of watching STJ boys..............this was the most exciting game , hands down.