I was discussing law school ranking with a local attorney yesterday. What he explained is that schools are doing incredibly unscrupulous things to affect their US News ranking, including inflating employment opportunities in order to attract students. US News also includes the LSAT scores of incoming classes, so here is one immoral and enuthical thing St. John's and other schools have done:
SJU offers an inordinate number of full scholarships to applicants with high LSAT scores. The "only" stipulation is that you maintain an unweighted B average. Sounds simple enough, right? But nearly all law schools, including St. John's, grade on a curve. So after one year, a large number of students lose their scholarships, and are left to pay for the remaining years of law school on their own. It's okay, though. They served their purpose in boosting SJU's law school rankings and help attract the next class of freshmen.
Sounds pretty un-Catholic, unethical, and immoral. Kind of like offering honorarium PhD's and retracting them if the honoree doesn't donate before the awards ceremony (a Cecilia Chang idea that FH really liked).