Before my time. In those days, post college players would either play in the LI Press league (where the McIntyres tore it up), the Eastern League (a semi pro league), and Brooklyn Queens CYO unlimited division. Mel played CYO for St. Mary's Star of the Sea in Far Rockaway, and I saw him play in our parish gym. If I'm not mistaken Sonny Dove also played in that league.
R.I.P. Mel had a stellar career at SJU, and was the prototypical NYC kid who stayed home and made St. John's a tough out for anyone.