jumbo_peanuts
Active member
Trying to keep up with the main forum, this has been a heated discussion.
Tonight's (Monday) game will be really something to see. I don't envy the umpires at all in this one.
Personally, I don't have a problem with Utley's slide. It was a baseball play that had the worst possible outcome. Was his slide dirty and cheap? Yes it was. Do I think that Utley's intentions were to break Tejada's leg? Absolutely not. But if Harvey retaliates tonight, it will be a cheap, dirty baseball play, just as the slide was. If he hits someone, and they get seriously hurt, what happens then? Do people say oh well...sticking up for your teammate is part of the game? Or will people call for Harvey to be suspended as well?
I don't think Harvey can take a chance at retaliating. But if he does, he needs to be smart about it. He can't hit someone in the middle of the back with a fastball with a 0-0 count. That will be too obvious, and will be grounds for an ejection. Remember, you can be thrown out at any time. The ump doesn't necessarily have to give you a warning.
This whole situation is becoming bigger than the game itself, and thats a real shame because it will probably ruin the entire series between 2 good teams.
Tonight's (Monday) game will be really something to see. I don't envy the umpires at all in this one.
Personally, I don't have a problem with Utley's slide. It was a baseball play that had the worst possible outcome. Was his slide dirty and cheap? Yes it was. Do I think that Utley's intentions were to break Tejada's leg? Absolutely not. But if Harvey retaliates tonight, it will be a cheap, dirty baseball play, just as the slide was. If he hits someone, and they get seriously hurt, what happens then? Do people say oh well...sticking up for your teammate is part of the game? Or will people call for Harvey to be suspended as well?
I don't think Harvey can take a chance at retaliating. But if he does, he needs to be smart about it. He can't hit someone in the middle of the back with a fastball with a 0-0 count. That will be too obvious, and will be grounds for an ejection. Remember, you can be thrown out at any time. The ump doesn't necessarily have to give you a warning.
This whole situation is becoming bigger than the game itself, and thats a real shame because it will probably ruin the entire series between 2 good teams.