Josh Rosen or John Allen

[redfan259999888]

The Browns will most like probably select sam Duford.
Josh Rosen sat out tonights game with a concussion, so should we skip on him and pick a healthy Josh Allen (11-19 154 3TDs and 0Packs, in winning 37- 14.)
I only ask because players can become prone to concussions like Aikman.

If healthy I'd definitely go Rosen, but maybe it's better to go the safe route then gamble.
Lastly, just look at Wertz, another mid major QB who was the league MVP, because going down.

 

[Mean Gene]

I would definitely stay away from Josh Rosen due to his propensity for concussions already. This is not the first time he's had a concussion. I really like Josh Allen but the Giants could trade the pick, move down and add another pick from the swap and take a guy like Mason Rudolph from Oklahoma St.who has a big time arm. If they believe in Davis Webb then they should take Saquon Barkley.

 

[Andrew]

Not sure if Rosen has a propensity to concussions. The offensive line on UCLA was horrendous.

 

[Sjugrad13]

The Browns would be foolish to take Darnold over Rosen but they’re the Browns. I personally feel like Rosen would be very good immediately.

When it comes to Allen It may take awhile for him to settle in, because if you’re inaccurate in FCS football I don’t see how he would radically improve so quickly in the NFL.

 

[Dan V]

I don't think Rosen, Darnold or Allen are franchise QBs. If my team had the top pick I'd take Barkley in a heartbeat. Jets fan by the way.

 

[Wolfie]

We need OL upgrades desperately; LBs, CBs, before we need QBs. It may make sense to trade down and gain extra picks throughout the draft. I’d rather do that than waste the #2 pick (I pray!) on ‘developing’ the ‘next’ QB (and if Mr. Rosen, cringing every time he’s hit!). Let’s be smart with this opportunity, following a dreadful season.

 

[L J S A]

Trade down. Mayfield is better than every guy named in this thread anyway.